loader from loading.io

The Leaky Bucket: Why Women Leave HVACR and What Leadership Can Actually Fix

Women in AEC: Wine After Work

Release Date: 09/30/2026

Prioritization Beats Productivity: Autonomy, Appreciation, and Culture show art Prioritization Beats Productivity: Autonomy, Appreciation, and Culture

Women in AEC: Wine After Work

Firms promote their strongest technical people into leadership and then give them almost no training. When a team struggles, leaders often blame the team. Amanda Van Der Heiden has seen this play out across dozens of organizations, and she argues the problem usually starts with how people are being led. Amanda and Bryce talk about how to get to the real reason someone wants out, and how to make core values stick after the launch. They cover how to adapt your leadership style without losing yourself, and what has to be in place before a leader can hand over real autonomy. Amanda explains...

info_outline Nobody at Work Is Your Friend: Relationships, Boundaries, and the Right Fit show art Nobody at Work Is Your Friend: Relationships, Boundaries, and the Right Fit

Women in AEC: Wine After Work

Every career advice list says to protect your relationships. Almost nobody explains what that looks like day to day. Julia Hurley has built a real estate business, a political career, and an athlete management company on relationships, so she knows the how. Julia and Bryce compare matchmaking in real estate and recruiting, and why buyers and candidates are both getting choosier. Julia explains how she teaches college athletes to be the CEO of their own lives by separating the people who support them from the people who manage their money and careers. She shares her rule of thumb for rental...

info_outline Leadership Is a Craft: High-Agency Leadership in AEC show art Leadership Is a Craft: High-Agency Leadership in AEC

Women in AEC: Wine After Work

Most AEC professionals move into leadership without any training for it. Engineering school didn't teach it and architecture school didn't either. So we copy whoever led us and hope it works. Zack Tomlin argues there's a better way, and that architects and engineers are wired to learn leadership as a craft. Zack built Maple Engineering from a two-person operation at a Raleigh public library into a 20-person firm and sold it after 12 years. He explains why leading highly technical experts calls for high-agency leadership instead of command-and-control. He walks through the five levels of his...

info_outline The Leaky Bucket: Why Women Leave HVACR and What Leadership Can Actually Fix show art The Leaky Bucket: Why Women Leave HVACR and What Leadership Can Actually Fix

Women in AEC: Wine After Work

Bryce just got back from Women in HVACR in Indianapolis, where she spoke to a room full of owners and managers about a number that should keep them up at night: women are leaving the trades at roughly three times the rate they are getting hired into them. Every job fair booth, every high school program, every recruiting push is water poured into a bucket with a hole in the bottom. This is not a DEI session. There is no slide arguing that diversity is good for business. This is a retention conversation built for the owner who has one woman on a crew of nine and cannot figure out why she is...

info_outline The Four Rungs on the Ladder: Why AEC Firms Hire Women and Lose Them Anyway show art The Four Rungs on the Ladder: Why AEC Firms Hire Women and Lose Them Anyway

Women in AEC: Wine After Work

Barb Allen spent 20 years on commercial job sites, starting as a carpenter apprentice in 1997 and working her way up to superintendent. She was the first woman her company had ever hired out of college for that track. She left the built environment in 2022 after a meeting where leadership told her she was "difficult to work with," then admitted nobody could say how. That meeting became a book. In OneLadder to Leadership, Barb names four gender specific challenges as rungs on an unsafe ladder: missing, broken, sticky, and slippery. In this conversation she breaks down all four, tells the story...

info_outline Architecture as a Society-Making Tool, Told From a War Zone show art Architecture as a Society-Making Tool, Told From a War Zone

Women in AEC: Wine After Work

Architecture is usually discussed as a service. A client has a need, a firm delivers a building, everyone moves on to the next project. Dr. Marwa Al-Sabouni makes a harder argument. She says the built environment is one of the strongest forces shaping whether people in a place trust each other, and that the consequences of getting it wrong can take generations to show up. She would know. Marwa is an architect based in Homs, Syria, who stayed through the war and wrote about what she was watching in real time. In this episode she and Bryce talk about how decades of zoning and redevelopment...

info_outline Burned Out and Anxious? What Your Food Has to Do with It and all the Food Recalls show art Burned Out and Anxious? What Your Food Has to Do with It and all the Food Recalls

Women in AEC: Wine After Work

Episode Summary:In this enlightening episode, we welcome Valerie Hawkins, a dedicated nutritionist and self-concept coach specializing in helping women tackle anxiety, burnout, and overwhelm. Drawing from her extensive background as a working mom and former engineer, Valerie shares her personal journey through the challenges of anxiety and burnout, offering valuable insights into how nutrition can significantly impact mental health and overall well-being.

Valerie’s transformative

info_outline Super-Architect: Craft, AI, and the Future of the Profession show art Super-Architect: Craft, AI, and the Future of the Profession

Women in AEC: Wine After Work

Architects have been losing ground for years, and the industry keeps explaining it away with fee pressure, schedule pressure, and software. Beau [Last Name] has a less comfortable answer. He says the profession's own craft has declined, and that decline is exactly why architects keep getting moved further from the decisions that matter. His case runs like this. When drawings are incomplete and coordination is loose, somebody has to fill that gap, and lately that somebody is the builder. The builder absorbs the risk, then reasonably takes the authority that comes with it. Beau and Bryce get...

info_outline Stop Playing Small: How a Clear Vision Unlocks Your Career and Life show art Stop Playing Small: How a Clear Vision Unlocks Your Career and Life

Women in AEC: Wine After Work

info_outline Designing Care, Not Just Buildings: Healthcare Design and AI show art Designing Care, Not Just Buildings: Healthcare Design and AI

Women in AEC: Wine After Work

Great healthcare design is invisible. You feel calmer, you find your way, your family has a place to rest, and you never notice the hundred decisions that made it happen. Kristin Green, a healthcare architect at Earl Swensson Associates (ESa) in Nashville, builds her whole practice around that idea. In this episode, she walks through what it actually takes to design hospitals that balance operational efficiency with genuine, patient-centered care. We get into the human details and the hard tradeoffs. Why she starts every project by leaving her ego at the door. How ESa levels the room so the...

info_outline
 
More Episodes

Bryce just got back from Women in HVACR in Indianapolis, where she spoke to a room full of owners and managers about a number that should keep them up at night: women are leaving the trades at roughly three times the rate they are getting hired into them. Every job fair booth, every high school program, every recruiting push is water poured into a bucket with a hole in the bottom.

This is not a DEI session. There is no slide arguing that diversity is good for business. This is a retention conversation built for the owner who has one woman on a crew of nine and cannot figure out why she is already looking, and for the leader watching a $22,000 replacement cost hit the P&L for the third time this year and calling it a fluke. Bryce walks through the real representation numbers, the four reasons women actually leave, the single factor that moves retention more than everything else combined, four shifts you can start this week, and a 30/60/90 day plan you can run without anyone's permission. There is also a self-audit exercise in the middle, so grab a pen or hit pause when you get there.

For HVACR and trade firm owners, field managers, operations leaders, and anyone in AEC who is tired of paying to replace the same role over and over.

About Bryce

Bryce Batts is the co-CEO of Career Collective, an AEC-focused recruiting and coaching firm, and the founder of Bryce Batts Consulting, where she runs a 16-week engagement helping firms rebuild hiring, retention, and leadership systems. She has spent more than a decade recruiting in the built environment, is a certified career coach, the author of The Career Architect, and the host of Women in AEC: Wine After Work. She speaks regularly on talent systems, leadership, and women in the trades.

What we cover

  • Why women leaving HVACR is a leadership problem, not a pipeline problem

  • The real representation numbers, and why the 45% growth stat is misleading

  • What turnover actually costs, and why it never shows up on the P&L as turnover

  • The four explanations leaders give, and what exit research says instead

  • Reason one: harassment, and the 80% number that does more daily damage

  • Reason two: isolation and why being the only one compounds everything

  • Reason three: childcare, accommodations, and PPE that does not fit

  • Reason four: the promotion path nobody ever wrote down

  • The single biggest retention lever, and why most managers have never been told about it

  • Four shifts, each with something you can do this week

  • The stay audit exercise, and the one question to end it with

  • A 30/60/90 day plan

Key takeaways

  • Recruiting harder makes a retention problem worse, not better. If the back door is open, more spend at the front door just means you lose more people faster while every metric on your recruiting dashboard says you are winning.

  • The manager is the retention strategy. A positive relationship with a direct manager is consistently the number one retention factor for women in the trades. Not pay, not benefits, not the values page on your website.

  • Turnover is a margin problem that got miscategorized as an HR problem. Replacing a skilled trade employee runs $15,000 to $30,000, and construction turnover can run 50% to 200% of the departing person's salary. It hides in overtime, recruiting spend, and callbacks.

  • Practical barriers are operational fixes, not cultural ones. Properly fitting PPE, scheduling, and parental accommodations require someone to place an order and update a document. That is exactly why it is damning when they do not get done.

  • Fix the system, not the individual. An arrangement you build for one person and never write down leaves when she does, and the next person fights the same fight alone.

Do this week

  1. Pull your last three complaints and read what happened after they were filed. If the answer is "I talked to them," that is a conversation, not a resolution.

  2. Ask every person on your team what their next role is. If they cannot answer, neither can you.

  3. Pull your PPE and scheduling policies and ask who each one was designed for. Then go look at what is physically in the supply room.

  4. Name one connection point you can create in the next 30 days for anyone who is the only one on their crew. Put a date on it.

Sources referenced

CSG Talent, IWPR, ACHR News, She Builds the Nation, Construction Owners Association (2025), People Element (2025–26)

Resources + links

Connect with Bryce