First Offer vs Final Offer — Turning a $500 Inbound into a 4-Figure Package
Release Date: 12/08/2025
The #1 Thing Holding Creators Back (& its not follower count): Confidence, Imposter Syndrome, & Money Blocks That Sabotage landing brand deals
Accidentally Influential
🎧 OUR LAST EPISODE OF 2025 IS A BANGER: Let’s talk about the real reason most content creators undercharge, underpitch, and undervalue themselves — and why it has nothing to do with your follower count. In this raw, reflective episode, we’re digging into the creator mindset blocks that kill your confidence, especially around money, pricing, brand deals, and your own worth. Whether you’re a beginner creator, educator-turned-entrepreneur, or scaling into 5-figure deals, this is the inner work that will take your content business to the next level. What We Cover: The limiting...
info_outline
The $18K Video, UGC Wins, & Money Lessons from 2025 (Unfiltered Creator Q&A)
Accidentally Influential
Welcome back to Accidentally Influential! In this unfiltered year-end wrap-up, we’re getting reflective and real about what worked, what flopped, and what PAID OFF in 2025. We’re diving deep into the highest-earning videos, lowest brand deal offers we accepted, exact income from UGC, and real numbers from retainer deals, ad usage, affiliate income, and more. Whether you're a content creator, UGC creator, educator, coach, or digital product seller, this episode is your permission slip to dream bigger and price smarter heading into 2026. Join the Not an Influencer Creator Club...
info_outline
Why Affiliate-Only Deals Are Undervaluing You — and What to Do Instead
Accidentally Influential
Think affiliate links are the key to making money online? Think again. In this real-talk episode of Accidentally Influential, Kate and Teanna unpack the truth about affiliate marketing — and why, for most creators (especially educators and digital product sellers), affiliate-only deals are watering down your brand and leaving serious money on the table. With over $500,000 in brand partnerships under our belts — and less than $10K in affiliate income — we’re pulling back the curtain on: Join the Not an Influencer Creator Club Waitlist → 🔥 What You’ll Learn in This Episode:...
info_outline
First Offer vs Final Offer — Turning a $500 Inbound into a 4-Figure Package
Accidentally Influential
Are you still accepting $250 brand deals because you “don’t want to scare the brand away”? 🫠 In this episode of Accidentally Influential, we're walking you through the exact brand deal negotiation strategy we teach inside our Creator Club — including a full breakdown of how to turn a $500 inbound into a $2,000+ brand partnership without burning the bridge or sounding pushy. This is your behind-the-scenes look at how content creators, UGC creators, and influencer educators are landing paid sponsorships, negotiating ad usage rights, and scaling their income with brand deals — even...
info_outline
How $10K+ Brand Deals Actually Work (Boundaries, Burnout, and Reality (Unfiltered Q&A)
Accidentally Influential
In this no-filter Q&A episode, Kate Robb and Teanna go deep into the questions creators are actually asking — from shady brand deal contracts to their most surprising “I made it” moments. Whether you're a beginner UGC creator or scaling your influencer business, this episode is packed with real-talk strategies, creator money wins, and a behind-the-scenes look at building a brand in the creator economy. We break down: The biggest red flags to watch for in influencer contracts How Kate made $18,000 off one brand video The ad rights most creators don’t know they’re...
info_outline
What to Charge Brands for Content: The 4R Pricing Framework for Brand Deals
Accidentally Influential
Pricing your content shouldn’t feel like pulling numbers out of thin air. In this episode of Accidentally Influential, Teanna and Kate get into the exact details of how to price your brand partnerships — and finally answer the question we know you're all asking: 👉 "What should I charge for a brand deal?" We’re breaking down: Why pricing feels so hard (and how to stop guessing) The industry standard base rate formula for creators The 4R Pricing Framework: Reach, Relevance, Rights, and ROI How to charge for things like usage rights, exclusivity, deliverables & more Why...
info_outline
How to Pitch Brands So They Say Yes (A Repeatable 5-Step Method)
Accidentally Influential
If you’ve ever typed out a pitch email not knowing what the heck you're doing, mayyybe thought it was a little cringe, only to be ghosted by the brand — this one’s for you. Whether you’re an educator-turned-creator, a UGC strategist, or someone sitting on a small-but-mighty audience that loves your recommendations… pitching brands is no longer optional. It’s a non-negotiable skill in the modern creator economy — and we’re breaking down exactly how to master it. Inside this episode, we’re pulling back the curtain on our exact pitch framework — including the email Kate sent...
info_outline
5 Green Flags for Brand Deals That Don’t Suck (& How to Land Partnerships That Pay You What You’re Worth)
Accidentally Influential
Episode Summary: If you’ve ever wondered how to land brand partnerships that actually feel good... the kind that pay fairly, align with your content, and let you keep your creative freedom... this episode of Accidentally Influential is your new go-to guide. Hosts Teanna Scot and Kate Robb are breaking down the 5 green flags of a great brand deal, so you can stop saying yes to lowball offers, stop working with misaligned brands, and start positioning yourself like the business owner you are. Whether you’re an edu-creator, UGC creator, or content entrepreneur, this episode shows you how to...
info_outline
Why Engagement Beats Followers (And How We Land Brand Deals Without Huge Audiences)
Accidentally Influential
Let’s be honest: if you’ve ever found yourself saying, “I’ll pitch brands when I have more followers,” this episode is for you. We’ve both been there ...scrolling TikTok, watching creators with 100K+ audiences do paid partnerships and wondering when (or if) we’d ever be “big enough.” But here’s the truth no one told us early on: follower count is not the metric that gets you paid. Brands don’t care how many people COULD see your content, they care how many actually do. That’s where engagement rate comes in...and it's the single most...
info_outline
Accidentally Influential: The Journey Begins
Accidentally Influential
We didn’t start out trying to become “influencers.” In fact, we hated the term. But one viral TikTok, a few unexpected DMs, and some very naive pricing decisions later… we realized we were leaving real money on the table. In this juicy first episode, we’re pulling back the curtain on our edu-creator origin stories, the brand deals we fumbled (and the ones we nailed), and the mindset shift that turned our content into a business. If you’re creating educational content on social and not getting paid yet? You need to hear this. Hit play — and then go put that email in your bio....
info_outlineAre you still accepting $250 brand deals because you “don’t want to scare the brand away”? 🫠 In this episode of Accidentally Influential, we're walking you through the exact brand deal negotiation strategy we teach inside our Creator Club — including a full breakdown of how to turn a $500 inbound into a $2,000+ brand partnership without burning the bridge or sounding pushy.
This is your behind-the-scenes look at how content creators, UGC creators, and influencer educators are landing paid sponsorships, negotiating ad usage rights, and scaling their income with brand deals — even with under 20K followers.
Whether you’re a new creator, a coach with a growing platform, or an educator in the online space, this episode will show you how to stop undercharging and start positioning yourself like a business.
In This Episode, You’ll Learn:
- The LEVEL Framework to negotiate brand deals like a pro
- How to reply to a lowball email and turn it into a custom brand package
- Why ad usage rights and cross-posting can 2X your deal size
- What to say when a brand says “we don’t have budget”
- Why brands are willing to pay $2,500+ to small creators
- How to position yourself as a strategic brand partner (not just a content creator)
- The biggest mistakes we see creators make when pricing their content
- Real pricing examples based on industry data and experience
- Why your follower count doesn’t matter as much as your clarity
Case Study in This Episode:
Meet “Stuck Sally” — a fictional but realistic UGC creator and educator with:
- 20K TikTok followers
- 5K Instagram followers
- 800-person email list
- Niche: beginner rock climbing tips
- Content: tutorial-focused, safety-forward, high-trust
We break down how Sally:
- Gets an inbound offer for $500
- Uses the LEVEL Framework to counter with options
- Lands a $2,300 deal with paid ad usage, stories, and repurposed content
💰Spoiler: Her brand deal package includes less than 60 seconds of video — but way more strategy.
Referenced at 17:00 → Sally's package options:
Sally’s Package Options:
Option A — Organic TikTok (Base Package)
- 1 TikTok video featuring the kit
- No usage rights
- No exclusivity
- Rate: $700 (This puts her at 3.5% of her following on TikTok and provides a slight raise from $500 to establish a more realistic baseline)
Option B — Cross-Platform Visibility
- 1 TikTok video
- 1 Instagram Reel
- 1–2 IG Story slides for CTA (“Here’s the kit I used!”)
- Rate: $1,200–$1,500** (Because cross-posting & stories drastically boost ROI)
Option C — Add Ad Rights
- Everything in Option B
- PLUS 30-day ad rights to run the video on paid channels
- Rate: +$300–$400 add-on**
Option D — Multi-Video Gear Series
- 2–3 TikTok/Reel videos over 30 days
- Story sequence per video
- 30–90 day ad rights
- Optional email placement (“Gear I’m Testing This Month”)
- Rate: $2,000–$3,000+
Your Creator Challenge This Week:
👉 Walk through the LEVEL Framework with a current or past inbound.
If you don’t have one, write a pretend pitch from a dream brand and practice your counter offer like it’s real. This is how you prep for the partnerships you want.
Resources + Links Mentioned:
This Episode is Sponsored by Tailor Brands
If you're a content creator who's ready to start treating your platform like a business — this is for you.
We used Tailor Brands when launching Not an Influencer Creator Agency to form our LLC, and it took less than an hour, start to finish. No confusing forms. No legal stress. Just a clean dashboard and step-by-step process made for creators like us.
From helping you file your LLC, get your EIN, set up a business bank account, and even track your income and expenses, Tailor Brands is the one-stop business builder for creators, educators, and entrepreneurs.
💼 Ready to make it official?
Just search "Tailor Business Builder" or head to tailorbrands.com to get started today.
Ready to Build a Real Creator Business?
You don’t need 100K followers. You need strategy.
Accidentally Influential is the no-fluff podcast for creators, educators, and online entrepreneurs who want to build a business without becoming a full-time influencer.
With over $500K in paid brand deals under our belt and 500K+ combined followers, we’re showing you:
- How to land sponsorships with brands you love
- How to stop undercharging
- How to treat your platform like a business
- And how to build intentional influence with the skills you already have
🎧 Hit follow, leave a review, and tag us when you share! We’ll be in the DMs cheering you on.
Follow us on Instagram + TikTok → @notaninfluencerco
Keywords:
- how to negotiate brand deals
- content creator pricing strategy
- UGC pricing examples
- brand deal templates
- how to land paid sponsorships
- how to pitch brands as a creator
- creator brand deal strategy
- content creator business tips
- Instagram influencer income
- UGC creator with under 10k followers
- content creator legal & business setup
- how to monetize as an educator or coach
- social media income tips
- convert lowball offers into paid deals