QA39 Listener Questions, Episode 39

Pete and Roger answer six listener questions covering Coast FIRE strategies with GIAs, US 401(k) tax implications in the UK, record keeping for IHT-exempt gifts, Australian pension taxation for UK residents, pension contributions to avoid the £100k tax trap, and managing a £2M portfolio as Power of Attorney.

Shownotes: https://meaningfulmoney.tv/QA39 

 

01:17  Question 1

Hi Pete and Roger,
I’m 29 and working towards Coast FIRE within the next 2–3 years so I can begin a digital nomad lifestyle — working remotely while knowing my long-term retirement is taken care of.

Right now, I’ve got:
- £45k in a Stocks & Shares ISA
- £25k in a workplace pension (via salary sacrifice)
- A Lifetime ISA for a future house deposit (or later retirement)
- A fully funded emergency fund

I’ve already maxed out my ISA for this tax year and plan to continue doing that every year. But I have more money to invest now, and I know that to reach Coast FIRE on my timeline, I need to start using a General Investment Account (GIA).

Here’s where I’m stuck: I want to keep things simple and tax-efficient, but I feel a bit nervous about GIAs. I keep hearing about the “bed and ISA” strategy but don’t really understand how it works in practice or how to implement it over time.

Could you explain:
- How best to use a GIA alongside an ISA when working towards FIRE?
- How to manage capital gains and dividend tax efficiently?
- And how the bed and ISA approach actually works — especially for someone trying to keep things simple?

Thank you both so much — your podcast has been an incredible resource and a big part of why I’ve been able to take control of my finances.
Warmly, Pauline

12:22  Question 2

Hello Pete & Roger
I am very late convert to the podcast but have been ploughing through the Q&A for a few days now. I think I only have another 592 episodes to get through so should be up to date by the end of the week !!

I am not sure whether this has been covered or not. I have a 401K plan that has been hibernating in the USA for 20 years. I have only recently started looking at it and now need to understand the tax implications. I have tried to read HMRC guidelines on tax treaties etc but get even more confused than before.

My current belief is that the provider will pay this money out by means of US issued cheque (not a problem) but withhold 30% tax (a problem).

How will HMRC treat this? The usual sources http://unbiased.co.uk for one run for the hills on finding information about this, is this an area you can provide guidance, but obviously not advice as I know you cannot through the podcast.
Regards, Stephen

16:10  Question 3

Hi Pete & Roger,

Like so many people I am really impressed, not just with your knowledge and great communication skills, but that you put out such life changing content. You’re providing us with the means to help ourselves in this financial world as well as letting us know when to seek professional help.

On to my question: we’re (wife and I) retired (late-60s) and are lucky enough to have more than enough to comfortably live on, thanks to DB & state pensions, house price inflation etc. Not really through any financial planning but just having been born at the right time! So we do now have an IHT liability. We have a joint second death Whole Of Life policy (in trust) in place for potential IHT and have given help with house deposits for our children.

We also are gifting to the kids out of our excess income and would like your thoughts on the type of record keeping needed for this. We have letters stating the intention to give the gifts, recording who to etc. We keep completed IHT403 forms which we update annually. We also have a monthly/annual spreadsheet of income/expenses which demonstrates our surplus and keep track of expenses with the MeMo transaction tracker (thanks for that). These are all in our ‘WID’ file (again thanks to you for that). What we’re not sure about is any documentation that might be needed to evidence the figures. Income is straightforward with P60s, statements of interest/dividends. However, what is required for expenses? Can’t really keep all supermarket receipts etc and even bank/credit card statements would be quite bulky over several years. Not sure if we’re overthinking but don’t want to leave a difficult task for our kids when we’re gone.

Thank you both again for all the good you are doing
Simon

20:33 Question 4

Brian (in Australia)
Thank you for all your podcasts and videos but I think I may have to sign up to the academy to fully get my head around all the UK rules.

We are looking to move to the UK from Australia - we have no UK govt pension entitlements but are retired with personal Australian private superannuation account pensions. The pension income payments and withdrawals are all tax free in Australia but will the UK government apply a tax on these pension payments once we are UK residents?
 
Thanks again for all your useful information.
Regards, Brian

22:55  Question 5

Hi Roger (and Pete),

I had a question which is boiling my brain far more than it should and I was hoping you could include it in one of your Q&A episodes.

I'm in the fortunate position of being caught by the £100k 'tax trap' due to being paid a bonus for the first time in a number of years. This particular first-world problem is being made all the worse because my daughter will start nursery next year so in addition to the 60% tax charge on my bonus, we would also lose the 30 free hours of childcare we currently have access to.

I currently salary sacrifice roughly £5,000 of salary into my pension (which my employer matches) and this holds my income at £99,000. However there is no option for me to do any kind of 'bonus sacrifice'. My only choice is to receive the bonus payment net of tax & NI through PAYE and then make a payment into my personal pension (a Vanguard, low cost multi-asset fund, just like you taught us!). I think I'm right in saying my pension provider will claim back the basic rate tax automatically for me, and I can then claim back the other 20% via my tax return with HMRC paying this extra 20% back to me directly.

So far so easy, but what I can't work out is just how much I have to pay in to my pension in order to take all of the bonus payment out of my taxable income. Presumably its not the net amount extra that gets paid into my bank account on the month my bonus is paid because this will also be net of NI, meaning I wouldn't have paid enough in to avoid the £100k trap. Assuming my bonus payment was £10,000 (I don't know the exact figure yet but its likely to be around this amount), could you talk through how to calculate the net payment I need to make into a personal pension to achieve the desired result? As a follow up to this, if HMRC send me a cheque (very 1990's) for say £2000 of refunded higher rate tax, do I need to pay this into my pension in the next tax year to avoid having it counted towards my taxable income in that financial year?

Please keep up the great work that you both do, you've really helped me get my financial life in order after an extremely difficult period in my life. Thank you both!
Jimmy

27:29  Question 6

Hi Pete and Rog,

Firstly, a huge thank you for all the insight and support you continue to offer. The impact of the Meaningful Money Podcast is immense—I’ve personally benefited so much from your free content over the years.

I'll keep this as brief as I can:

My great aunt (now 84) has built a substantial portfolio over decades—about £2 million across ~60 individual company shares, with approx. £1.3 million in a GIA and the rest in S&S ISAs. She also holds £400k in fixed-term bonds, savings accounts, and premium bonds. Sadly, she was diagnosed last year with dementia and Alzheimer’s and now resides in a care home.

I am her Power of Attorney and want to act in her best interests—simplifying her affairs and ensuring tax efficiency, especially regarding her legacy. She has no spouse or children but wishes to leave money to nieces, nephews, and charities.

Here’s my working plan:
- Offset gains in the GIA by selling loss-making investments (totalling £30k–£40k) alongside some of the profit making investments to reduce market exposure without incurring CGT costs.    
- Liquidate all shares in her S&S ISAs and transfer funds into cash ISAs with decent interest rates
- Leave most of the GIA portfolio untouched to benefit from the CGT uplift on death

Am I broadly on the right track for tax efficiency and sensible financial planning? Should I seek formal advice to ensure I'm doing the best by her?

Thanks again for all you do—it really matters.
Best regards, Josh