JOHN CHISUM: Can AI Write Christian Music?

Song Revolution Podcast – Season 4

 

TITLE: JOHN CHISUM: Can AI Write Christian Music?

HOSTS: John Chisum

EPISODE SUMMARY

In this thought-provoking episode of Song Revolution, John Chisum tackles one of the most pressing issues facing today’s music creators: artificial intelligence in songwriting.

Fresh off multiple interviews at the National Religious Broadcasters (NRB) convention, where AI was the dominant topic of conversation, John unpacks the realities, risks, and responsibilities surrounding AI-generated music. From deep fakes and copyright confusion to spiritual discernment and creative integrity, this episode dives deep into what AI means for Christian songwriters.

John makes a clear and passionate case: AI may be a powerful tool, but it can never replace the calling, humanity, and spiritual formation of a real songwriter. This conversation challenges creators not to take the easy way out, but to steward their gifts faithfully in a rapidly shifting technological landscape.

 

EPISODE TOPICS

• The rise of AI-generated music
• Experiences at NRB and industry-wide AI discussions
• Rights, revenue, and reputation concerns in publishing
• AI “scraping” artist catalogs and copyright implications
• Spotify removing millions of AI-generated tracks
• Deep fakes and reputational harm
• Theological and spiritual questions about AI worship songs
• When AI can be a helpful tool versus a creative shortcut
• Why real songwriters still matter
• Growing as a communicator instead of outsourcing creativity

 

KEY HIGHLIGHTS

• AI Is Here to Stay
  John acknowledges that AI technology will only improve. Like the digital shift of the late 20th century, we are in a major cultural and creative transition. The key question is not whether AI exists—but how we respond to it.
• Rights, Revenue, and Reputation
  AI-generated songs often “scrape” existing catalogs to mimic an artist’s style, raising serious concerns about intellectual property and theft. Who owns these songs? Who gets paid? And what happens when an artist’s name or likeness is misused through deep fakes?
• Humanity Cannot Be Scraped
  While AI can generate polished production and flawless vocals, John argues that it lacks pathos, testimony, and authentic spiritual experience. A great song carries one clear idea rooted in real human emotion. Production may impress, but stripped down to piano or guitar, the song must stand on its own.
• Prompt Writing vs. Songwriting
  If a creator inputs only a prompt and receives a finished song, John draws a firm line: that is not songwriting. True songwriting involves crafting lyrics, shaping melody, wrestling with structure, and allowing personal testimony to flow into the work.
• Appropriate Use of AI
  John is not anti-technology. Using AI to generate a demo of a fully written lyric and melody can be a legitimate tool. The issue is not assistance—it is substitution.
• Spiritual Discernment in the AI Era
  Can God use AI-generated lyrics if they contain truth? Possibly. Truth is truth. But Christian communicators are called to more than efficiency—they are called to communion with God. Songwriting is not just output; it is formation.
• Don’t Shortchange the Process
  The labor of crafting lyrics and melodies over time shapes the songwriter. Taking creative shortcuts may produce sound, but it does not produce growth.

 

FINAL TAKEAWAY

Technology may accelerate production, but it cannot replace calling.

AI can be a tool—but it must never become a substitute for the Spirit-led, deeply human process of writing songs. God called you to be a songwriter not simply to produce music, but to spend time with Him, to grow, and to communicate truth from your own heart.

Do not shortchange yourself. Do not surrender your voice. Steward your gift, embrace the discipline, and create as a real human being empowered by the Spirit of God.

 

RESOURCES & LINKS:

Link to the John Piper ChatGPT clip John mentioned in the episode.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CIMZH7DEPPQ

 

Check out Nashville Christian Songwriters!

NashvilleChristianSongwriters.com

 

FREE DOWNLOAD - The Complete NCS Songwriting Guide: Proven Principles for writing better songs, stewarding your gifts, and building a lasting life of Christian songwriting.

https://courses.nashvillechristiansongwriters.com/guide

 

Join the NCS ONE SONG CHALLENGE!

https://courses.nashvillechristiansongwriters.com/one-song-challenge

 

Be a part of our community of songwriters from across the globe. Join NCS Community!

https://www.nashvillechristiansongwriters.com/ncs-community

 

Real people writing real songs - check out NCS Collective

https://www.nashvillechristiansongwriters.com/ncs-collective/