724 | Streamer Fishing for Trout with Tommy Lynch - Fish Whisperer, Pere Marquette River, Small Creek

#724 Show Notes: https://wetflyswing.com/724 

Presented by: Drifthook Fly Fishing

Sponsors: https://wetflyswing.com/sponsors 

Streamer fishing for trout is all about movement, and few people understand it better than Tommy Lynch. In this episode, Tommy breaks down his four-step framework for fishing streamers, explains the difference between suicide fish and would-be predators, and shares why most anglers aren’t getting the full potential out of their sink tips. If you’re looking to up your game on big browns in small creeks, this episode is packed with tips you won’t want to miss.

Episode Chapters with Tommy Lynch on Streamer Fishing for Trout

How to Fish Streamers Like a Jerkbait for Big Browns

Streamer fishing isn’t just about casting and stripping. It’s about making your fly move like a wounded baitfish—something trout can’t resist. Tommy explains that the best way to do this is by mimicking the action of a jerkbait, specifically the black and gold No. 13 Rapala, which has been deadly on brown trout for years.

Four Key Techniques for Streamer Action:

1. Down Swat - A true jerkbait-style movement where you “swat” the fly through the water to make it dart and dig before swimming out.
2. Straight Strip - A steady retrieve with small breaks in rhythm, mimicking an injured baitfish.
3. Proper Placement – You want the fly close enough for the trout to see and react but not so close that it spooks them.
4. Reading the Fish – Watch for slight movements—if a trout shifts left or right, it’s game on.
   The Two Types of Trout: Suicide Fish vs. Would-be Predators

When streamer fishing, Tommy breaks down trout into two categories: suicide fish and would-be predators. Understanding these can help you dial in your approach.

Suicide Fish
These trout sit tight against structure, waiting to ambush anything that moves. They don’t need much convincing—just proof of life. A quick down swat and pause can be enough to trigger a strike. Key to this is using slack to let your sink tip actually sink. Just casting and waiting won’t cut it. You need to shake out line or reach toward the fly to help it drop.

Would-Be Predators
These fish aren’t actively hunting but can be triggered into striking. They often hang in slower water, watching for an easy meal. A straight strip in the middle of the retrieve keeps their interest, but the real trick is slowing down near the end. That pause can be enough to flip a passive trout into attack mode.

Whether you’re targeting an aggressive fish or coaxing a hesitant one, understanding their behavior is key. And remember—just because you bought a sink tip doesn’t mean it’s sinking. Use it right, or you’re just dragging it through the water.

Essential Streamers for Trout Fishing

When it comes to streamers, Tommy keeps a variety on hand. From classic muddler minnows to modern swim flies, each has a purpose.

Go-To Patterns

• Muddler Minnow – A timeless fly, perfect for imitating minnows, especially during fry season.
• Sex Dungeon – A bigger, articulated fly that moves aggressively in the water.
• Blane's Game Changer – A segmented fly with a lifelike swimming action, great in slow water.
• Great Lakes Deceiver – A swim fly with a broad, gliding motion, ideal for provoking strikes.

Matching the hatch is key. Some days, trout want small minnows on a five-weight. Other days, they’ll chase down a big meal. Adjusting your presentation—whether it’s a slow jerk or a fast retrieve—can make all the difference.

Small Stream Brown Trout: Stealth and Strategy

Fishing small creeks for brown trout is a whole different game. Tight water, overhanging trees, and spooky fish make for a serious challenge. But the reward? Lots of fish and zero crowds.

Key Tactics for Small Creeks

• Stealth is everything – Move slowly and blend in. Stand still, and trout may swim right up to you.
• Cast upstream – This keeps your fly in the trout’s line of sight while reducing drag.
• Short leaders work – A 6- to 7-foot leader helps control the fly without excess slack.
• Walk far, fish hard – Many of these waters require hiking in. The more effort, the fewer people you’ll see.

Michigan’s small streams are packed with wild brown trout, and many are rarely fished. If you’re willing to put in the miles, you’ll find fish that are aggressive, unpressured, and ready to eat.

Finding Big Browns in Tiny Creeks

Small creeks may be tight, but they hold more fish than you’d think—including some big browns. The trick is knowing where to look.

What to Look For

Heavy structure – Undercut banks, log jams, and tag alder thickets create safe zones for trout.
Hidden water – Spots that seem impossible to fish often hold the best fish.
Naive trout – Less pressure means more aggressive fish willing to hit a well-placed fly.

Fishing these small creeks is an adventure. You’ll crawl through brush, jump logs, and make tight casts. But the reward? Wild trout in untouched water. And sometimes, a true giant where you least expect it.

Winter Streamer Fishing: When to Go and What to Expect

Streamer fishing in winter isn’t always easy, but it’s worth it. The fish are bigger, more aggressive, and fewer people are on the water. Tommy follows weather windows, layering up to chase those cold-water eats.

Key Seasonal Patterns

• Fall (October–November) – Browns are aggressive but defensive. They hit flies to chase off intruders, not necessarily to eat.
• Post-Spawn (December–January) – Big fish get hungry. They need calories after spawning, so the strikes are all about feeding.
• Late Winter (February–March) – Fewer bites, but larger fish. Some exhausted browns even take swung flies, which is rare.

When streamer fishing slows down, steelhead take center stage. By late November, Tommy swaps the strip flies for two-handed swing flies. If you’re tough enough to fish in freezing temps, you might just hook into a monster.

The Salmon Invasion: How It’s Changing Michigan’s Trout Fishing

Salmon runs bring big fish and big crowds. But the rise in anglers chasing Chinook has made traditional trout fishing tougher. Once, anglers could target big browns feeding on salmon eggs. Now, with more people pushing upriver, those spots are packed early in the season.

The solution? Hike farther, fish hidden creeks, and find spots that others overlook. The browns are still there—you just have to work harder to reach them.

Show Notes:  https://wetflyswing.com/724