loader from loading.io

AI During Trial: Jury & Verdict. Part Two with Michelle Gessner [Ep 171]

Trial Lawyer Prep

Release Date: 07/29/2026

AI During Trial: Jury & Verdict. Part Two with Michelle Gessner [Ep 171] show art AI During Trial: Jury & Verdict. Part Two with Michelle Gessner [Ep 171]

Trial Lawyer Prep

In our last episode, we learned about Michelle Gessner's recent trial in North Carolina, where she was forced to pivot from a regular audio/video presentation, using modern technology, to a courtroom with no microphones, no TVs, no projectors and a single power outlet (already claimed by the clerk and the court reporter!). Michelle used AI to help adapt to this unexpected turn of events, asking it how to craft a visual presentation under these unique circumstances. Today, we learn how it unfolded. You could feel the courtroom change as the case progressed, and this was a quick trial: starting...

info_outline
AI for Winning Courtroom Visuals: Case Study with Michelle Gessner [Ep 170] show art AI for Winning Courtroom Visuals: Case Study with Michelle Gessner [Ep 170]

Trial Lawyer Prep

My guest today,  Michelle Gessner, joined the podcast back in December of 2024, where we discussed her $21 million verdict against Wells Fargo. Today she's back with the story of a recent verdict success in North Carolina, which suddenly hit an unexpected twist. The case was planned out to make use of high tech video equipment and software, as you would find in a standard, modern equipped court room. But then, it was moved to courtroom that had no technology; in fact, only a single outlet with extension cords. No microphones, no TVs, no projectors. Just old-school visual tools: easels,...

info_outline
Juror Attention Spans: The Science Every Trial Lawyer Needs to Know [Ep 169] show art Juror Attention Spans: The Science Every Trial Lawyer Needs to Know [Ep 169]

Trial Lawyer Prep

What if our assumptions about modern attention spans aren't accurate? We are all used to hearing that people have much, much shorter attention spans these days, thanks to social media, clickbait, algorithms, and a constant barrage of information. While those things certainly represent a major shift in our day to day reality over the past 15+ years, that doesn't necessarily mean that we're paying less attention than we used to. In fact, it's more of a rewiring of our brains, thanks to technology, leading to a state of continuous partial attention. Why is this important to trial law, case...

info_outline
Using Case Framing in Discovery with Tony Edwards [Ep 168] show art Using Case Framing in Discovery with Tony Edwards [Ep 168]

Trial Lawyer Prep

For an effective discovery, case framing should start as early as possible. But be ready to pivot! Don't let the other side get the jump on you in framing a case, and put you in catch-up mode from the start. You need to start framing a case at intake, especially for higher-value cases. But, as our guest points out today, you also need to be ready and willing to pivot, should new facts arise, or if a new framing will in fact strengthen your case. Tony Edwards is a personal injury lawyer in Oklahoma, and shares stories and wisdom from his decades of experience. We talk about a trucking case...

info_outline
Trial Strategy in Action: Timelines, Sequencing, and What Wins [Ep 167] show art Trial Strategy in Action: Timelines, Sequencing, and What Wins [Ep 167]

Trial Lawyer Prep

There is a crucial difference between timelines and sequences, and if you want jurors to see your case as plainly as you see it, you need to pay close attention. Today we explore not just how timelines help jurors understand the case quickly, but why that is: the psychology and brain science behind retaining information. Timelines are a curated visual picture of the case, sequencing is about the order of presenting evidence. Similar, yet each with their own distinct psychologies. I know, not all lawyers use timelines, but they can be very effective, and focus groups help you recognize and fine...

info_outline
Depo Clips or Live Witness: The Call That Won the Case [Ep 166] show art Depo Clips or Live Witness: The Call That Won the Case [Ep 166]

Trial Lawyer Prep

Five days before trial, a team chose to play defense witness deposition clips, instead of calling the witnesses live. Instinct tells us, training tells us: do it live. Live is better. Live is more persuasive. Live is much more catchy for cross exam. Video puts people to sleep. However, what I walk you through today really boils this down to a primacy question, or in other words, first impressions. In the case above, focus group data showed that clips were having far more impact in setting the stage, and locking in that first impression. So the team pivoted, and the trial took on an entirely...

info_outline
Using AI in Trial Prep and the Courtroom, with Matthew Fornaro [Ep 165] show art Using AI in Trial Prep and the Courtroom, with Matthew Fornaro [Ep 165]

Trial Lawyer Prep

AI has hit the mainstream, and not just in everyday life, but in trial law and legal prep. The days of startups and experimental software have quickly evolved to comprehensive, through and reliable AI-based programs, used by countless law firms and lawyers every day. As a result, it feels like we are racing to keep up. To jump on the bandwagon before it's too late, yet making sure you're using AI in accurate, and ethical, ways. Matthew Fornero is a South Florida business litigator, with over 20 years of courtroom experience and a long track record of representing small businesses,...

info_outline
3 Steps to Get Reliable Juror Feedback [Ep 164] show art 3 Steps to Get Reliable Juror Feedback [Ep 164]

Trial Lawyer Prep

Running a good focus group is really a lot like conducting a good trial: Fundamentally, it's about understanding people.   And you don't need a psychology degree to do so. If you have an innate understanding for human behavior, relationships, biases and different means of communication, then you already have the instinct to make the most of your focus groups.   Today's episode breaks down three key steps to be organized and prepared for your next group. Armed with these tools, you can then hit the ground running and really connect with juries and clients.   We cover: Setting...

info_outline
Witness Prep Strategies That Embrace Brain Science [Ep. 163] show art Witness Prep Strategies That Embrace Brain Science [Ep. 163]

Trial Lawyer Prep

Heading into deposition prep, your clients are typically nervous, anxious, overwhelmed and lacking confidence.   They are most likely in a situation they have never found themselves in before, and undoubtedly the stakes feel very high.   But we need to get them to focus, to remember, to think and answer clearly, and to let go of their fear and uncertainty.   This episodes focuses on three clear, distinct strategies that also help you remember how to get the most out of your clients at this crucial juncture. Clients will feed off of not just your confidence, but your calm...

info_outline
Trial Lawyers and Time Management: Wisdom from Dina Cataldo [Ep 162] show art Trial Lawyers and Time Management: Wisdom from Dina Cataldo [Ep 162]

Trial Lawyer Prep

We're all busy trial lawyers and specialists, typically juggling multiple cases at once.  Time management and organization is crucial, and we can't allow ourselves to get overwhelmed, to risk impacting not just the case but our own health and well-being. It's worth taking the time to make sure your tasks and workflow are efficient, your calendar flows logically, and your habits are positive and healthy. Even just a few minutes' pause for retrospection and meditation can make a huge difference. And I've been right in the thick of it lately myself! As a trial consultant, I was getting two...

info_outline
 
More Episodes

In our last episode, we learned about Michelle Gessner's recent trial in North Carolina, where she was forced to pivot from a regular audio/video presentation, using modern technology, to a courtroom with no microphones, no TVs, no projectors and a single power outlet (already claimed by the clerk and the court reporter!).

Click here to catch Episode 170 and hear the back story for today's episode.

Michelle used AI to help adapt to this unexpected turn of events, asking it how to craft a visual presentation under these unique circumstances.

Today, we learn how it unfolded.

You could feel the courtroom change as the case progressed, and this was a quick trial: starting on a Monday, verdict by the end of day Tuesday. Literally two days.

In fact, there were some assets to the old-school, analogue approach: better eye contact with jurors, fewer distractions, and more movement.

Using what was learned from the focus groups before the trial, and the creative AI suggestions for presenting evidence, Michelle was able to correctly anticipate the jury's emotional reactions as the witnesses unfolded.

With AI helping between trial days to make sure she'd met her burden of proof, Michelle then gave her closing argument with foam boards instead of any PowerPoint slides or technology.

And the result: she won.

If you want more trial prep strategies just like this, but in more depth and delivered straight to your inbox, grab my email newsletter that I send out each month:

https://www.larricklawfirm.com/newsletter

In this episode, we cover:
  • How the visuals created with AI significantly engaged the jury.
  • Focus groups provided valuable insights for trial strategy.
  • How word choice is so important in your presentation.
  • Closing arguments were enhanced by using visuals instead of technology.

Remember to check out Episodes 128 & 129, featuring Michelle Gessner and her $21 million dollar verdict against Wells Fargo:

You can also watch today's episode on my YouTube Channel:

AI During Trial: Jury & Verdict. Part Two with Michelle Gessner [Ep 171]
 
Learn more about my guest Michelle Gessner:

Michelle Gessner is one of the few lawyers, if not the only lawyer, in North Carolina who has both Big Law and Big Company defense experience, as well as 10 years of employee-side employment litigation experience, which she has been nearly exclusively handling since 2015. 

Michelle possesses a deep understanding of the many challenges employees face dealing with wage theft and other illegal employment practices.

Prior to its formation, Michelle gained extensive experience in all legal issues facing the retail, restaurant, and hospitality industries by serving as the Chief Litigation and Employment Law Counsel for publicly traded companies such as Family Dollar Stores, Inc. (FDO), Darden Restaurants, Inc. (DRI), Big Lots Stores, Inc. (BIG) and TriNet (TNET). Michelle also served as the SVP, General Counsel, and Chief Administrative Officer for Ovation Brands, a privately held $1 billion restaurant company.

Follow and Review:

We’d love for you to follow us if you haven’t yet. Click that purple '+' in the top right corner of your Apple Podcasts app. We’d love it even more if you could drop a review or 5-star rating over on Apple Podcasts. Simply select “Ratings and Reviews” and “Write a Review” then a quick line with your favorite part of the episode. It only takes a second and it helps spread the word about the podcast.

Have a trial or mediation coming up and want to test with a focus group? Book a free consultation call with Elizabeth to learn more:

Don’t miss out on the Trial Lawyer Prep Newsletter that is delivered right to your email with extra tips and ‘how to’ information. Join the newsletter here: