Impact of Enrollment Pressure on Admissions Teams and Students
Release Date: 09/24/2024
New Models for Consolidation in Higher Education
Changing Higher Ed
Consolidating Higher Education: The Community Solution Model This episode of the Changing Higher Ed® podcast features Dr. Michael Horowitz, Chancellor of The Community Solution Education System (), who discusses using innovative models for higher education consolidation as an additional category in or alternative to traditional . Horowitz highlights the system's unique approach, a collaborative model prioritizing resource optimization and expertise sharing among member institutions while maintaining individual identities. The conversation addresses , including increasing closure rates and the...
info_outline
Washington Update: Implications of the 2024 Elections on Higher Ed — Part 2
Changing Higher Ed
Higher Education Policy in the 119th Congress Part 2 of this podcast continues with Tom Netting, president of TEN Government Strategies and , examining ways in which the outcome of the 2024 US elections will transform higher education. Drawing from over three decades of policy expertise, Netting provides an insider’s perspective on the anticipated changes a Trump administration and the 119th Republican-controlled Congress could bring to higher education. Netting analyzes shifts in key Congressional committees, focusing on the implications for higher education funding, accreditation, and...
info_outline
Washington Update: Implications of the 2024 Elections on Higher Ed — Part 1
Changing Higher Ed
Higher Education Expert Analysis of Anticipated Federal Policy Changes Under the Incoming Administration Part 1 of this two-part podcast welcomes back Tom Netting, president of TEN Government Strategies and our Washington Update expert, to examine how the 2024 US elections will transform higher education. Drawing from over three decades of policy expertise on The Hill, Netting provides an insider's perspective on the anticipated changes a Trump administration and Republican Congress could bring to higher education. The conversation unpacks major shifts within the Department of Education, from...
info_outline
How Faculty Diversity Drives Enrollment: The PhD Project’s 90% Success Model
Changing Higher Ed
Faculty Diversity: A Business Case for Higher Education Success When the PhD Project launched in 1994, you could count the number of diverse students at major business school recruiting events on one hand. Today, after 30 years of systemic change, the initiative has graduated over 1,700 faculty members of color with an extraordinary 90% completion rate – nearly double the national average for doctoral programs. Even more remarkable, 97% of these graduates stay in academia. But here’s what makes this story particularly compelling for university leaders: Research has shown that the presence...
info_outline
Understanding the Crisis of Confidence in Higher Education
Changing Higher Ed
The Declining Trend in Public Confidence Higher Education has a reputation crisis. Public confidence in higher education is declining dramatically. In 2015, a Gallup poll revealed that the vast majority of Americans expressed a great deal of confidence in higher education, with only 10% reporting little to no confidence. By 2024, public confidence shifted significantly: only about a third maintained a great deal of confidence, while a startling 33% now held little to no confidence. This mirrors a broader trend of declining trust in American institutions. Dr. Drumm McNaughton and Dr. Courtney...
info_outline
What Americans Really Think of Higher Ed: Insights from New America's Varying Degrees 2024
Changing Higher Ed
Despite media narratives of declining confidence in higher education, new survey data reveals 80% of Americans view college costs - not value - as the primary barrier to enrollment. While only 36% think higher education is "fine how it is," bipartisan support remains strong, with a majority of both Democrats and Republicans favoring increased government funding for affordability. On this episode of Changing Higher Ed® podcast, Dr. Drumm McNaughton speaks with Kevin Carey, Vice President for Education and Work at New America, and Sophie Nguyen, Senior Policy Manager with the Higher Education...
info_outline
Accreditation NECHE Style: From Prescriptive to Nuanced
Changing Higher Ed
Innovation in Higher Education Accreditation: How NECHE Leads Change Gone are the days of counting library books and checking boxes. With average presidential tenure plummeting to less than five years and a wave of institutional mergers reshaping American higher education, understanding the evolution from prescriptive to nuanced accreditation has become paramount for institutional survival. In this podcast, Dr. Drumm McNaughton, in discussion with Dr. Lawrence "Larry" Schall, President of the New England Commission on Higher Education (NECHE), shares insights on how accreditation has...
info_outline
Improving Public University Systems at Scale
Changing Higher Ed
In this podcast, host Dr. Drumm McNaughton welcomes guest James R. Johnsen, the former President of the University of Alaska System, who is now a Vice President of Executive Search for Greenwood Asher & Associates. Johnsen discusses his new book, "," which examines the importance of and challenges facing public university systems across the U.S. What higher ed leaders will gain from this podcast: Understanding Public University Systems in Higher Education Governance A comprehensive overview of public university systems, their prevalence, importance, and the challenges they face. The...
info_outline
Effective University Mergers & Lessons in Stability from PASSHE
Changing Higher Ed
In this episode of Changing Higher Ed, Dr. Drumm McNaughton interviews Dr. Daniel Greenstein, former Chancellor of the Pennsylvania State System of Higher Education (PASSHE), to explore strategic efforts in guiding one of the largest transformations in U.S. higher education. Over his six-year tenure, Greenstein led PASSHE’s integration of six universities into two larger institutions, tackling financial challenges, increasing program diversity, and improving student outcomes—all while maintaining each institution’s unique identity and local impact. The discussion covers the complexities...
info_outline
STEM Enrollment Growth: Online Labs Drive Student Retention
Changing Higher Ed
This episode features host Dr. Drumm McNaughton and guest Dr. Caitlin Runne-Janczy, Chief Academic Officer for Scientific Interactive, a company that provides hands-on and virtual science lab experiments to students. Drumm and Cait focus on the growing demand for online science lab courses, particularly in STEM fields. Cait discusses the results of a recent survey that found a significant increase in online lab enrollment and a corresponding decrease in on-campus enrollment. They also explore the challenges and opportunities of delivering quality online lab experiences, including safety...
info_outlineThe Real Cost of Chasing Numbers: Balancing Enrollment Pressures and Student Success
Teege Mettille, a veteran with over 20 years in higher education enrollment, discusses the growing challenges faced by admissions counselors and the potential impact on student engagement. Drawing from his book "The Admission Counselor Malaise," Mettille shares insights on the evolving landscape of college admissions and offers strategies for maintaining a balance between institutional needs and student success.
Key Discussion Points
Current Challenges in Higher Education Enrollment:
- Decreasing number of high school graduates and public funding
- Increasing skepticism about the value of college education
- Pressure on institutions to maintain and increase enrollment numbers
Impact on Admissions Counselors:
- Growing applicant pools without proportional staff increases
- Shift from student engagement to data management and administrative tasks
- Misalignment between job expectations and actual responsibilities
Effects on Student Engagement:
- Reduction in meaningful one-on-one interactions with prospective students
- Increased reliance on mass communication strategies
- Potential compromise in matching students with the right institutions
Strategies for Improvement:
- Leveraging technology to enhance personal connections
- Rethinking hiring and training practices for admissions counselors
- Focusing on yield rates through targeted, personalized outreach
Balancing Institutional Needs and Student Success:
- Recognizing the disconnect between revenue goals and counselor motivations
- Celebrating the human side of admissions work
- Adapting success metrics beyond pure enrollment numbers
Three Key Takeaways for University Presidents and Boards
- Acknowledge the misalignment between institutional enrollment goals and admissions counselor motivations.
- Focus on outperforming market position incrementally rather than attempting drastic changes.
- Celebrate and support admissions counselors' mission-driven work in addition to meeting enrollment targets.
Final Thoughts
Mettille emphasizes the need for a balanced approach in college admissions, one that meets institutional needs while preserving the core mission of guiding students to their best-fit educational experiences. He calls for creativity and adaptability in addressing these challenges, highlighting the potential for technology and strategic planning to enhance rather than replace the human element in admissions.
Read the transcript on our website: https://changinghighered.com/impact-of-enrollment-pressure-on-admissions-teams-and-students/
#HigherEducation #HigherEdEnrollment #CollegeAdmissions
About Our Guest
Teege Mettille is a thought leader in the field of college admissions with extensive experience on both the institutional and vendor sides of the industry. As a speaker, his primary focus is on addressing and solving pressing issues within the college admissions profession, ensuring ethical practices, and promoting the well-being of students over mere enrollment numbers.
Teege is the author of the insightful book "The Admissions Counselor Malaise: Addressing the staff morale crisis in college admissions," which provides a critical yet constructive analysis of the current state of college admissions. The book has been praised for its candid approach to diagnosing systemic problems and offering actionable solutions for improvement. Teege's expertise and practical advice make it an invaluable resource for professionals in higher education.
About the Host
Dr. Drumm McNaughton is the founder, CEO, and Principal Consultant at The Change Leader, Inc. A highly sought-after higher education consultant with 20+ years of experience, Dr. McNaughton works with leadership, management, and boards of both U.S. and international institutions. His expertise spans key areas, including accreditation, governance, strategic planning, presidential onboarding, mergers, acquisitions, and strategic alliances.
Dr. McNaughton’s approach combines a holistic methodology with a deep understanding of the contemporary and evolving challenges facing higher education institutions worldwide to ensure his clients succeed in their mission.