EP 267 Does AI Make you More or Less Creative? (Paintbrush vs Photocopier)
Release Date: 12/21/2025
AI Literacy for Entrepreneurs
Most of the leaders Sira Laurel works with look like they're winning. Inside, they're exhausted. Sira is an executive coach and facilitator who works on leadership, organizational design, cognitive load, trust and nervous system capacity. She has watched organizations get very good at making work faster while getting worse at deciding what the speed is for. AI raises the stakes on that question. Her starting point is that capacity covers far more than time. It includes attention, decision-making, emotional bandwidth and creative energy. A tool can hand back hours on the calendar while draining...
info_outlineAI Literacy for Entrepreneurs
This episode skips the tools, the prompts, and the latest model release. It goes somewhere more philosophical. started out as an archaeologist and anthropologist. He was the kid who loved museums and Indiana Jones. Since then he has worked across history, contemporary art and culture in Dublin, Istanbul, Beijing, Hong Kong, Pittsburgh and Doha. Now he works as a strategist helping organizations make sense of complexity and line up around change. His starting point is that change itself is old news. Humanity has absorbed huge technological shifts again and again. The new part is the speed....
info_outlineAI Literacy for Entrepreneurs
A previous president from Lindenwood University (a former IBM executive) stands up in town halls and tells people he uses Claude - that it helped him organize the financial report. HR follows and says they used Gemini for an employee questionnaire. Then James Hutson PhD. goes and asks employees whether they understood that as permission. The answer? 'No. The policy says I'll get fired if I use it.' That gap is the subject of this episode. James is Senior Professor and Director of AI-Enabled Academic Transformation at Lindenwood University, with two PhDs - the first in art history, the second...
info_outlineAI Literacy for Entrepreneurs
Most organizations govern AI the same way cities govern speeding. They set a rule, then punish people who break it. Dr. Eugene Chan thinks that's the least interesting tool available. He's a behavioural scientist - founder of the consultancy Behavieural and Professor of Business at Tyndale University - and his argument is that punishment is a lagging response to a problem you could have designed out. His analogy is a speed camera versus a speed bump. Both reduce speeding. The camera does it by fining you after the fact, and it needs maintenance forever. The speed bump does it by making the...
info_outlineAI Literacy for Entrepreneurs
Episode description Julie Cole and her co-founders started Mabel's Labels in a Hamilton basement 23 years ago, back when customers were still nervous about typing a credit card number into a computer. They figured out early that they weren't really running a label company - they were running a tech company that happened to make labels. Nothing off the shelf did what they needed, so they built it themselves. Which is why her read on this moment carries some weight. She's watched every technology wave since. She's not a skeptic and she's not a cheerleader. She uses AI, has a clear personal rule...
info_outlineAI Literacy for Entrepreneurs
"We need AI" is the most common brief in business right now. David Cohen's read on what it means: usually nothing in particular. David is the founder of Superposition, a consultancy for data and AI consultancies - a meta consultancy, as he calls it. He's spent his career inside both big and boutique consulting shops, which makes him refreshingly blunt about what's actually happening in the services world right now. His diagnosis is that we're still in the solution-in-search-of-a-problem stage. Everybody's curious. Everybody's excited. There's enormous movement, enormous hype, and very few real...
info_outlineAI Literacy for Entrepreneurs
Episode description Everyone's arguing about whether AI can be trusted. Almost nobody's asking the harder question underneath it. Grace Gravestock has spent more than twenty years leading change management on some of the highest-profile technology projects around - including the team that set the stage for the $67B Dell EMC integration. Her verdict on why AI pilots stall is unsentimental: it's the same reason ERP stalled, and CRM before that. People aren't using the technology the way it was intended. You can have the best tools in the world, and if people don't use them, it doesn't matter....
info_outlineAI Literacy for Entrepreneurs
In the final episode of the Podcast-to-Book series, host sits down with change leader and AI education lead (Sun Life) for a human-first conversation about what actually makes AI adoption work. They talk productivity vs room-for-life, why one-prompt culture is snake oil, the shift from prompt engineering to context engineering, and the simplest enterprise question that changes everything: “What would make Monday easier for employees?” Episode summary Susan closes out the Podcast-to-Book sprint with a conversation that feels like the point of the whole series: AI isn’t a tool problem....
info_outlineAI Literacy for Entrepreneurs
Most companies do a few AI trainings, run some pilots, and then stall. In this episode, host argues the only real future-proofing strategy is continuous AI literacy. She breaks down what “continuous literacy” actually includes (skill, judgment, workflow, norms), the predictable failure modes of the AI literacy divide, and a simple flywheel you can run monthly so capability keeps compounding. Episode summary Susan opens with a familiar pattern: a burst of AI excitement, a deck called “AI Strategy 2025” a few clever workflows… and then reality hits. Tools change. Policies shift....
info_outlineAI Literacy for Entrepreneurs
Host sits down with sales strategist , founder of Sales Beyond Scripts, to talk about the real ways AI is changing revenue, planning, and scale. They cover AI as a thinking partner, how to use it across departments in a small business, why audits matter more than hype, and how mindset quietly determines whether you treat AI as a threat or an advantage. Episode summary This episode is part of Susan’s 30-episodes-in-30-days “podcast to book” sprint for Swan Dive Backwards. Susan and Gazzy zoom in on the selling process first. Then they zoom out to the whole business. They talk about three...
info_outlineAI can feel like a creativity cheat code… or like the death of originality. In this short, punchy solo episode, Susan argues the truth is simpler: AI doesn’t create creativity. It creates options. Creativity still belongs to the driver—your taste, courage, and point of view.
Episode summary
Susan tackles a question she hears constantly: does AI expand creativity or flatten it?
Her answer: it depends on how you’re using it. If you use AI like a photocopier—generate a first draft and ship it unchanged—you’re not becoming more creative. You’re becoming more efficient at being generic.
But if you use AI like a paintbrush—as a sparring partner, a possibility engine, a constraint generator, or a remix assistant—it can shorten the distance between blank page and something you can shape.
The episode is a practical reset on what creativity actually requires in the AI era: taste, discernment, point of view, and the courage to be a little weird on purpose.
Key takeaways
-
AI doesn’t create creativity. It creates options.
Creativity still requires intent, judgement, and discernment.
-
Paintbrush vs Photocopier is the core distinction.
-
Photocopier: you accept the default output and publish it.
-
Paintbrush: you use AI to generate raw material, then you curate and shape.
-
People can “spot AI writing” when there’s no point of view.
Generic writing usually means the human outsourced the messy parts: emotional clarity, lived experience, and risk.
-
Creativity needs both taste and courage.
AI doesn’t do courage.
Taste is what you choose—and what you reject.
-
Better prompts aren’t about asking for “the answer.”
They’re about asking for raw material: angles, metaphors, structures, constraints, and pushback.
Ways to use AI like a paintbrush
Try these modes when you feel stuck:
-
Sparring partner: “Push back on this.” “Argue the opposite.” “What am I not seeing?”
-
Possibility engine: “Give me 20 angles.” “Give me metaphors.” “Suggest surprising structures.”
-
Constraint generator: “Make this an 8-word active headline.” “Explain it for a 12-year-old.” “Turn it into a story with a clear villain.”
-
Remix assistant: “Turn this into a framework.” “Make it a checklist.” “Turn it into a debate.”
The mini exercise Susan gives you
Pick something you’re working on (a post, pitch, talk, plan). Then ask AI:
-
What’s the most boring version of this?
-
What’s the boldest version of this?
-
What’s the truest version of this for me?
Then you decide what to keep, amplify, or reject.
That’s the creative act.
Episode highlights
00:02.36 — The core question: does AI make you more or less creative?
00:18.46 — “It depends who’s driving” (AI amplifies you)
00:55.04 — Core belief: AI creates options, not creativity
01:23.10 — Paintbrush vs photocopier framing
01:38.81 — The photocopier trap: shipping first drafts unchanged
02:16.38 — Why people can “tell it’s AI” (patterned, POV-less output)
03:03.35 — Creativity requires taste + courage (AI doesn’t do courage)
03:19.86 — Choose the paintbrush path
03:37.29 — Use AI as a sparring partner (push back / argue opposite / what am I missing?)
03:47.10 — Use AI as a possibility engine (20 angles, metaphors, surprising structures)
04:18.08 — Use constraints to force originality (8-word headline, etc.)
05:16.92 — What “taste” actually is: what you choose (and reject)
05:45.66 — Ask for raw material, not “the answer”
06:05.56 — Mini exercise setup (post, pitch, talk, plan)
06:21.82 — Three-question prompt: boring vs bold vs true
07:27.10 — When AI makes you less creative: avoiding the thinking
07:38.96 — Don’t quit AI—change the prompt
07:51.10 — Ask for “stranger / truer / mine”
08:03.45 — Wrap: creativity is in the driver’s hands
08:19.29 — Quick ask: rating + review
If you’re feeling creatively stuck, don’t ask AI to be creative for you.
Ask it to help you explore—then use your taste to choose.
And if you’re enjoying this 30-day podcast-to-book sprint, leave us a quick rating + short review to help more people find the show
Connect with Susan Diaz on LinkedIn to get a conversation started.
Agile teams move fast. Grab our 10 AI Deep Research Prompts to see how proven frameworks can unlock clarity in hours, not months. Find the prompt pack here.