Holidays - Why “More People, More Problems” Is a Thing

Episode 45 · Family Dynamics, Holidays & “More People, More Problems”

In this episode of the Imperfect Men’s Club, Mark and Jim talk about the chaos, comedy, and emotional landmines of family gatherings during the holidays, especially Thanksgiving. They unpack why every family is “messed up in its own special way,” how that shows up around the table, and what men can actually do about it instead of just bracing for impact.

They walk through a simple framework for understanding family dynamics and layer it over real stories: aging parents, kids scattered across the country, in-laws, politics, addiction, sobriety, and the quiet pressure to “keep the peace” even when you’re tired of being the peacekeeper.

---

What they cover

• The flywheel of life & relationships with others
  How family dynamics fit into the broader framework of money, worldview, self, health, profession, and relationships (broken into male and female).

• Life in phases: 0–10, 10–20, 20–30, 30–40 and beyond
  Why holidays feel totally different depending on your age and role: kid at the card table, young parent, empty nester, or grandparent.

• The 5 components of family dynamics (holiday edition)

  • Roles & structure: provider, nurturer, peacekeeper, the “drunk uncle,” and the new people showing up to the table.

  • Relationships: from close and harmonious to distant and strained, and how unresolved issues surface the minute everyone’s in the same room.

  • Rules: explicit and unspoken rules around timing, respect, language, and “no politics at the table” (and what happens when those rules get broken).

  • Communication: verbal and nonverbal cues, dirty looks, raised voices, and how authority and power actually play out.

  • Emotional health: affection vs distance, criticism vs support, and the trap of comparing your kids and life to everyone else’s.

• Traditions, kids & geography
  How traditions evolve as children grow up, move away, start their own families, and bring partners into the mix… and why “no kids at the table” holidays hit differently.

• Alcohol, emotions & conflict
  The difference between a couple beers with buddies and a drunk, emotional family gathering… and why some people are choosing not to drink at all during holidays.

• Standards, boundaries & enforcement
  Who makes the rules, who enforces them, and why staying silent about bad behavior is the same as condoning it.

• Adapting to change without losing yourself
  Grown kids, new partners, scattered locations, aging parents, estranged siblings, and learning when to engage… and when to simply let go.

---

Key ideas & takeaways

• Every family is imperfect; the question is what you choose to focus on: the dysfunction or the gift.

• “More people, more problems” is real, especially when you mix old history, new partners, alcohol, and politics.

• You always have a choice in how you show up: you don’t have to fix everything, win every argument, or say every thought out loud.

• Clear standards and boundaries protect the emotional health of the whole room, especially kids who are watching and learning.

• Comparison (your kids vs theirs, your life vs theirs) is a quiet, corrosive habit that can wreck your holiday from the inside out.

• With age and experience, peace often matters more than being “right.”

---

Questions to reflect on

• What role do you tend to play in your family during the holidays: provider, peacekeeper, exploder, ghost?

• Where are your relationships harmonious… and where are they clearly strained?

• What unspoken rules are running your family gatherings, and do any of them need to change?

• How do alcohol, politics, and comparison impact the emotional climate at your table?

• What would it look like this year to show up with less ego and more calm?

---

How to support the show

If this episode hits home and you think other men could benefit from it, especially this time of year, go to Apple Podcasts, drop a rating, and leave a short review. It helps the show reach more men who need to hear they’re not the only ones dealing with messy, imperfect families.