Dave Ramsey Eviscerates Co-Host George Kamel for Preaching the 4% Rule
Release Date: 11/22/2023
This TikTok Finfluencer Says His 76-Year-Old Dad Can Spend 7.5% and Still Grow His Portfolio. Let's Check the Math.
The Power Of Zero Show
Viral TikTok “finfluencer” Tyler Gardner claims his 76-year-old father can stay 100% in stocks. David McKnight breaks down exactly where that approach falls apart. Additionally, he reveals the retirement planning strategy that actually makes a 100% stocks allocation safe, so a market downturn doesn’t force you to sell at the worst possible time. Show Notes In this episode, David McKnight fact-checks a viral TikTok video from “finfluencer” Tyler Gardner explaining why his 76-year-old father is still invested 100% in stocks. David stresses that he doesn't have a problem with being...
info_outline
Five Years from Retirement? Do This.
The Power Of Zero Show
The five years before retirement are what David McKnight calls the Retirement Danger Zone, a window where a stock market crash could trigger Sequence of Returns Risk and even derail a well-designed plan. In this episode, he breaks down the retirement planning strategies that build an income floor, create a Volatility Shield, and protect your tax rate before it’s too late. Show Notes In this episode, David McKnight talks all things “Retirement Danger Zone”, the 5-year time window that precedes your retirement. When you’re 20 years from retirement and the stock market crashes,...
info_outline
I Have $1 Million in Taxable Accounts and $1 Million in IRAs. How Can I Prepare for Higher Taxes?
The Power Of Zero Show
If you've built up $1M in your IRA and $1M in taxable investments, David McKnight has a warning: every year that money stays put, the IRS gets to vote on your tax rate. He breaks down a retirement planning strategy for gradually converting your IRA to Roth – fast enough to beat rising rates, slow enough to avoid painful brackets. In this episode, David McKnight looks at what you should do if you have accumulated $1M in taxable investments, and $1M in traditional IRAs and are concerned about the possibility of higher taxes in retirement. He stresses that having money in IRAs...
info_outline
Best Reason to Delay Social Security To Age 70
The Power Of Zero Show
When is a good time to start your Social Security? David McKnight reveals why smart retirement planning means waiting until age 70 for reasons that have nothing to do with a bigger check… and everything to do with the years in between being your best window for Roth conversions. In this episode, David McKnight addresses one of the most common questions he gets from people approaching retirement: “When should I start taking Social Security?” David believes that there’s a compelling reason for having 70 as your default Social Security claiming age – and that isn’t so that...
info_outline
Should You Stop Roth Conversions at the 22% Tax Bracket?
The Power Of Zero Show
Should you stop your Roth conversions at the 22% tax rate, or push into the 24% bracket? David McKnight responds to a viewer's detailed case for stopping early, revealing why optimizing this year's tax bill can be the wrong retirement planning move over a 30-year horizon. You'll discover his "rip the band-aid off" approach and why saving money on taxes today isn't a victory if it costs you more tomorrow. In a recent video, David McKnight explained why he believes the 24% tax bracket is the sweet spot in the current tax code for Roth conversions. In this episode, he addresses a...
info_outline
Why Not Put Your Entire Retirement into 5.25% Treasuries? (Have You Won the Game?)
The Power Of Zero Show
Is putting your entire retirement planning strategy into 30-year treasuries really the safe bet it seems? David McKnight reveals why this approach could expose you to two hidden risks, and explains how the stock market and annuities might hold the real key to protecting your income. In this episode, David McKnight looks at whether putting your entire retirement portfolio into 30-year treasuries is the way to go. While it may seem like a pretty compelling argument, there’s a major problem with this strategy – and it comes down to two things: taxes and inflation. The U.S....
info_outline
Dave Ramsey’s 8% Retirement Rule: What Could Possibly Go Wrong?
The Power Of Zero Show
Dave Ramsey says retirees can safely withdraw 8% a year from the stock market, but does his retirement planning math actually hold up? David McKnight breaks down why Ramsey’s approach overlooks a critical risk, and why annuities may be the missing piece to sustainably boosting your retirement income beyond the traditional 4% Rule. In this episode, David McKnight examines Dave Ramsey’s 8% withdrawal rate claim and why retirement planning may need annuities, and not just the stock market. For Ramsey, you can take 8% per year out of your stock market portfolio in retirement, despite what...
info_outline
The Three Biggest Reasons Americans Hate Annuities
The Power Of Zero Show
Most Americans hate annuities and would tell you to avoid them… But what if the version you’ve been warned about isn’t the only option for retirement planning? David McKnight breaks down a strategy that’s quietly helping retirees sleep better at night and safeguard themselves against the 3 biggest annuities-related problems. In this episode, David McKnight looks at three perfectly legitimate reasons why Americans have been reluctant to embrace annuities, as well as a solution. The first problem is liquidity. David points out that one of the biggest fears in retirement is...
info_outline
Should High Earners Contribute to a Roth 401k?
The Power Of Zero Show
Should every dollar go into a Roth 401(k) if taxes will be higher? David McKnight reveals why that instinct could actually be one of the most expensive tax decisions a high-income earner can make when it comes to retirement planning. In this episode, David McKnight addresses two frequently asked questions: “If tax rates are going to be higher in the future, should I be putting every dollar into a Roth 401(k)?” and “Should I be converting as much of my IRA to Roth as quickly as possible?”. David believes that the current tax rates are as low as we’re likely to see in your...
info_outline
The Latest Proposal to Tax Roth IRAs: Should you be worried?
The Power Of Zero Show
Should you stop doing Roth conversions as part of your retirement planning after Senator Ron Wyden’s new legislation targeting specific retirement accounts? David McKnight breaks down the key aspects of the proposal and what it actually means for the average American (and their retirement). Show Notes In this episode, David McKnight looks at whether you should stop doing Roth conversions following Senator Ron Wyden’s introduction of legislation for taxing Roth IRAs. For David, 99.9% of Americans should continue investing in Roth accounts with a high degree of confidence. One of...
info_outlineDave Ramsey recently eviscerated his co-host George Kamel for preaching the 4% rule.
According to George, withdrawing only 4% of your savings is the easiest way to guarantee your money lasts throughout retirement.
George further adds that the 4% rule is a math-based approach to sustainable withdrawals in retirement.
For Dave Ramsey, the 4% is senseless and only geared toward stealing people’s hope for a brighter retirement.
He believes an 8% withdrawal rate is more sustainable since your savings will be growing at a rate of 12%; factor in 4% for inflation, and you’re left with 8%.
It’s clear Dave Ramsey is oblivious to the sequence of return risk, which could force you to run out of money 15 to 20 years early if you experience a series of negative returns in the first decade of retirement.
The fact is, even if you average 12% rates of return throughout retirement, you won’t be getting 12% every single year. Some years, you’ll get 20%, and other years you’ll get -26%.
David explains that the 4% rule gives you peace of mind that regardless of the swings in the market, you’ll have a reasonably high chance of not outliving your money.
Because Ramsey has millions of dollars, he has the license to utilize planning assumptions that are wildly at odds with history and academic research.
If you’d like a stress-free retirement, ignore Dave Ramsey’s advice and embrace strategies that are built on sustainable retirement planning principles like the 4% rule.
Mentioned in this episode:
David's books: Power of Zero, Look Before You LIRP, The Volatility Shield, Tax-Free Income for Life and The Infinity Code
PowerOfZero.com (free 3-part video series)
@mcknightandco on Twitter
@davidcmcknight on Instagram
David McKnight on YouTube
Get David's Tax-free Tool Kit at taxfreetoolkit.com