#594: Can Muscle Still Adapt Positively When Training Under Low Energy Availability? – Jose Areta, PhD
Release Date: 02/10/2026
Sigma Nutrition Radio
In this episode, Danny answers questions submitted by Premium subscribers. Questions Answered in This Episode: [00:05:13] Is eating too early (relative to chronotype) metabolically problematic? [00:16:55] Can plant-based diets reverse cardiovascular disease? [00:32:54] Are multivitamins useful insurance, or a waste with a good diet? [00:44:56] Does coevolution with foods determine human compatibility and benefit? [00:56:25] How should consumers choose supplement formulations and brands? [01:04:46] Folate vs folic acid: differences and best choice for women of...
info_outlineSigma Nutrition Radio
“The more we learn about the world, and the deeper our learning, the more conscious, specific, and articulate will be our knowledge of what we do not know, our knowledge of our ignorance. For this, indeed, is the main source of our ignorance — the fact that our knowledge can be only finite, while our ignorance must necessarily be infinite.” – Karl Popper To mark Sigma Nutrition’s milestone 600th episode (and 12-year anniversary), Danny and Alan examine several areas in which their views have changed, softened, strengthened, or remained stable over the lifespan of the podcast....
info_outlineSigma Nutrition Radio
This episode examines whether unprocessed red meat has a causal role in (1) type 2 diabetes risk and intermediate measures of glucose intolerance (insulin resistance, beta cell dysfunction, glycemic markers) and (2) cardiovascular disease (CVD) risk. While there is commonly observed risk signal from observational cohorts, there exist short-term randomized controlled trials (RCTs) that show largely null effects on glucose homeostasis. This had led to differing opinions and interpretations of the evidence base. Some feel that in the context of an otherwise healthy diet, there isn’t much to...
info_outlineSigma Nutrition Radio
This episode examines how exercise and nutrition interact to influence glycaemic control, with particular focus on the postprandial period (i.e., the hours after eating) and on “time-efficient” exercise strategies such as low-volume interval training. Dr. Jenna Gillen outlines the physiological basis for why muscle contraction can acutely reduce post-meal glucose excursions, why repeated sessions can accumulate into longer-term improvements in insulin sensitivity, and why the nutrition context (pre- and post-exercise feeding, carbohydrate availability, and energy balance) can meaningfully...
info_outlineSigma Nutrition Radio
In clinical practice effective nutrition, exercise, and obesity care is rarely about identifying the single “best” plan on paper. Instead, sustainable change depends on behavioral psychology: understanding the person’s context, motivation, barriers, and patterns, then co-designing practical steps that can actually be implemented in real life. David Creel PhD, RD is a clinical psychologist and registered dietitian working in weight management at the Cleveland Clinic. Dr. Creel discusses how clinicians can bridge the gap between “optimal recommendations” and what is most likely to...
info_outlineSigma Nutrition Radio
Omega-3 fatty acids (particularly EPA and DHA) have a long history in nutrition and cardiovascular medicine, yet the clinical trial literature is often perceived as inconsistent. This episode examines why some randomized trials show clear benefit while others show null or mixed findings, and how differences in trial design, dose, population risk, and outcome selection can materially change what we observe. A key theme is separating (1) the persistent cultural narratives around omega-3s (including origin stories that do not hold up well to modern evidence) from (2) the more precise, mechanistic...
info_outlineSigma Nutrition Radio
Conversations about brain health have been dominated by a competing mix of fatalism and over-promising, with aging framed as inevitable decline and “brain optimisation” sold through weak evidence. So how should we think about cognition across the lifespan? In this episode, we explore the idea that neuroplasticity does not disappear in adulthood, but instead continues to respond, for better or worse, to repeated behaviours and exposures. Much of what is labelled age-related cognitive decline may in fact reflect an accumulation of modifiable risk factors. We also dig into how to critically...
info_outlineSigma Nutrition Radio
This is a Premium-exclusive episode of the podcast. To listen to the full episode you need to be subscribed to . This episode examines dietary fiber through the lens of a practical, clinically relevant question: if higher fiber intakes are consistently associated with reduced chronic disease risk, what intake level should we be aiming for to meaningfully improve health outcomes? The discussion deliberately spans from common online claims that fiber is “not essential” (and therefore unnecessary), through to mechanistic reasoning and the highest-quality evidence we have for...
info_outlineSigma Nutrition Radio
Dr. José Areta and colleagues recently carried out a human intervention study examining how a pronounced, short-term energy deficit interacts with an aerobic training stimulus to shape endocrine, metabolic, and skeletal muscle proteomic adaptations. The core premise is that “low energy availability” is often discussed in a largely unidirectional risk framework, yet human physiology evolved under intermittent energy scarcity, and therefore adaptive responses may be more nuanced than “energy deficit equals impaired adaptation.” The study used tightly controlled diet and exercise,...
info_outlineSigma Nutrition Radio
While the term “hyperpalatable” has been used frequently for considerable time to refer to foods that are so appealing and tasty that they drive overeating, this term hasn’t been well-defined nor has there been a universal standard for what it means. One researcher who set out to create an objective definition for hyper-palatable foods (HPFs) is Dr. Tera Fazzino. Using specific defined thresholds of sugar, fat and salt combinations, Dr. Fazzino and colleagues have looked at the impact of consumption of these HPFs. In this episode, we delve into defining HPFs and their nutrient profiles,...
info_outlineDr. José Areta and colleagues recently carried out a human intervention study examining how a pronounced, short-term energy deficit interacts with an aerobic training stimulus to shape endocrine, metabolic, and skeletal muscle proteomic adaptations.
The core premise is that “low energy availability” is often discussed in a largely unidirectional risk framework, yet human physiology evolved under intermittent energy scarcity, and therefore adaptive responses may be more nuanced than “energy deficit equals impaired adaptation.”
The study used tightly controlled diet and exercise, repeated muscle biopsies, and dynamic proteomic profiling to quantify both abundance and synthesis rates of hundreds of individual muscle proteins. This enables a more granular view of “muscle quality” and phenotype than traditional bulk muscle protein synthesis measures.
The findings were incredibly interesting and could have implications for how we view the impact of energy deficits and exercise response.
We discuss the implications for athletes who routinely encounter transient within-day or multi-day energy deficits, for weight loss contexts, and for broader questions around healthspan and ageing biology.
Timestamps
- [02:27] Guest introduction
- [03:28] Research background and study design
- [12:18] Study findings: weight loss and endocrine responses
- [15:47] Muscle adaptations and proteomic analysis
- [21:47] Interpreting the results: evolutionary and practical implications
- [26:57] Mitochondrial proteins and muscle adaptation
- [28:44] Energy deficit as a stressor
- [34:26] Case study: female tour de france athlete
- [40:20] Implications for clinical populations
- [41:44] Future research directions
- [46:48] Key ideas segment (Premium subcribers only)
Related Resources
- Go to episode page (with links to studies)
- Join the Sigma email newsletter for free
- Subscribe to Sigma Nutrition Premium
- Enroll in the next cohort of our Applied Nutrition Literacy course
- X: @jlareta