#421: 3 Ways to Get More Gym Members (That Aren't Ads)
Behind Gym Doors | A Fitness Business Podcast
Release Date: 01/15/2026
450: Saving a Struggling Pilates Studio: Live Coaching With Mike Arce
Behind Gym Doors | A Fitness Business Podcast
Struggling pilates studio owner goes viral asking for help -- Mike Arce coaches her live on numbers, retention, ads, and pricing. Jess Landar runs a struggling pilates studio in Auckland, New Zealand. She posted on Instagram that she needed help, so Mike reached out and turned it into a live gym business audit. This is Part 1 of a two-part series. Her studio peaked at $15,000 NZD a month and had dropped to $10,000 when they sat down. Mike walks through her gym churn rate, her lifetime value, her ad data, and her pricing structure, and shows her the exact math that would triple her book of...
info_outline
449: Why Gym Ads Optimize for Leads (Not Members)
Behind Gym Doors | A Fitness Business Podcast
Fixing gym Facebook ads conversion tracking is part of how we get studios to $100K a month. Your ads manager sees fifty leads on one ad and six on another, calls the fifty-lead ad the winner, and kills the other one before ever checking what happened next. That is the blind spot behind most gym ad optimization strategy decisions. When your CRM and your Meta ads manager never talk past the lead stage, nobody actually knows which ad produced a member. The six-lead ad that closed two members just got cut so the fifty-lead ad that closed zero could get double the budget. Mike walks through...
info_outline
448: Why Gym Ads Fail (It's Not Your Ad Agency)
Behind Gym Doors | A Fitness Business Podcast
Want to see how we help gyms get to $100K a month? Here's the plan the best gym owners are following right now: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uMPx7b3_LOA Your ad agency did not lose you that member. Something else did, and it happened long before the ad ever ran. Paid ads get blamed for problems they did not cause. A great ad still fails if your Google reviews look shaky, if leads sit for hours before anyone calls, or if your team has no script for the close. More than 80 percent of consumers research a company before they ever click through on an ad, and gyms that respond to a lead...
info_outline
447: How to See Every Ad Your Gym Competitors Are Running
Behind Gym Doors | A Fitness Business Podcast
Curious what it actually looks like to build with us? Start here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uMPx7b3_LOA Mike found a competitor a mile and a half from one of his gyms. She has no idea he is watching. Studying competitors sounds like copying. It is actually the fastest way to find out where you already win and nobody else has noticed. One studio in this breakdown has 458 five star reviews, and not a single competitor ad in the market uses reviews as proof. In this episode you'll learn: — Why Mike is against competitor focused marketing, except for this one use case — The exact AI...
info_outline
446: AI Systems This Gym Owner Uses to Retain 856 Members
Behind Gym Doors | A Fitness Business Podcast
Curious what it actually looks like to build with AI instead of just talking about it? Start here: 856 members. Under 3 percent churn most months. One hire changed how this gym runs everything. Everyone assumes AI adoption means fewer people on payroll. Dave Rafuse spent more, not less, because the tool only pays off when someone builds it into the business first. Blended Athletics grew 23 percent, then 25 percent, then 28 percent over the last three years, and Dave says the systems that got them to 150 members never would have gotten them to 856. In this episode...
info_outline
445: 9 Meta Ads Mistakes Gyms Make (And It Costs Them Tens of Thousands of Dollars)
Behind Gym Doors | A Fitness Business Podcast
Want to see how we help gyms get to $100K a month? Here's the plan the best gym owners are following right now: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uMPx7b3_LOA Your ads aren't failing because of your audience. They're failing because of nine fixable mistakes most gym owners don't even know they're making. And the agencies running those ads may not be telling you. You are probably paying your agency to do things that should never be their job. Strategy. Budget. Offer. Reporting. At $800 to $1,500 a month, they're a vendor built for execution, not decisions. The gyms spending the same money on ads...
info_outline
#444: A Gym Owner's AI Playbook: How BFT Tysons Is Running on AI in 2026
Behind Gym Doors | A Fitness Business Podcast
Here's the plan the best gym owners are following right now: The gyms winning with AI right now are not using it to write emails. They built a machine learning algorithm that predicts who's about to cancel. They fired their ad agency and their bookkeeper. They have an AI employee living in Slack that nobody on the team can tell isn't human. Pav spent 20 years in Fortune 500 companies before opening BFT Tysons. His financial planning background and tech instincts put him in a different category than most gym owners touching AI right now. In this episode, Mike Arce sits down with one of the...
info_outline
#443: The Hidden Reason Your Gyms Ads Aren't Converting (It's Not the Ad)
Behind Gym Doors | A Fitness Business Podcast
🔥 Fire Your Ad Agency — LIVE Workshop for Gym Owners — June 16th, 1pm PT Learn why most gym ad agencies are costing you more than they're making you — and what to do instead. Limited seats. Register → GSDlive.com —————————————————— You're spending money on ads. The targeting is right. The creative is solid. And the leads still aren't coming in the way they should. It's not the ad. It's what happens after someone sees it. 82% of people who see your gym's ad don't call. They go do homework first. They check your Google reviews, your Instagram,...
info_outline
#442: 10 Ways to Make Your Gym More Valuable
Behind Gym Doors | A Fitness Business Podcast
🔥 Fire Your Ad Agency — LIVE Workshop for Gym Owners — June 16th, 1pm PT Learn why most gym ad agencies are costing you more than they're making you — and what to do instead. Limited seats. Register → GSDlive.com —————————————————— Two gyms. Same city. Both doing $1 million a year. One sells for $1.2 million. The other can't find a buyer. Same revenue. Completely different outcomes. Most gym owners have no idea what their gym is actually worth. The number they think they'd get if they sold tomorrow is probably way off. And the reason almost always...
info_outline
#441: The Decoy Effect: How to Structure Your Gym's Pricing to Close More Members
Behind Gym Doors | A Fitness Business Podcast
🔥 Fire Your Ad Agency — LIVE Workshop for Gym Owners — June 16th, 1pm PT Learn why most gym ad agencies are costing you more than they're making you — and what to do instead. Limited seats. Register → GSDlive.com —————————————————— Your pricing sheet is losing you sales every single day. Not your staff. Not your pitch. Your sheet. And the fix takes less than an hour. Most gym owners build their pricing sheet to look professional. What they're actually doing is handing prospects a reason to say "let me think about it." When someone walks...
info_outlineYour gym doesn’t have a lead problem.
It has a leverage problem.
Most gym owners think growth only comes from running more ads.
In reality, that’s just one of three levers you can pull and it’s usually the weakest one.
In this episode, I break down the three real ways to get more gym members (and more revenue) without just lighting money on fire with marketing.
You’ll learn:
-
The 3×3 growth grid we use with gyms scaling profitably
-
Why most gyms are stuck only pulling one lever
-
How to grow faster without increasing ad spend
-
How referrals, retention, and conversion multiply everything
-
Why operational clarity beats “more leads” every time
This is the exact framework used by gyms that consistently grow month over month while everyone else stays stuck or burns out.
If you want more members, more revenue, and more profit without guessing, this episode will change how you think about growth.