loader from loading.io

316 Why Your Middle-Priced Product Sells Best: The Compromise Effect Explained

My Digital Farmer | Marketing Strategies for Farmers

Release Date: 06/11/2025

364 CSA Buy Down Offers: Marketing Case Study with Thirsty Fruit Farm show art 364 CSA Buy Down Offers: Marketing Case Study with Thirsty Fruit Farm

My Digital Farmer | Marketing Strategies for Farmers

In this episode, I sit down with Krista Barzen-Hansen of Thirsty Fruit Farm (one of my students from Farm Marketing School!) to break down how her farm marketing has evolved and strengthened over the past year. In this farm marketing case study, we unpack: how customers discover her farm, how she nurtures leads, how she's constantly optimizing her "gateway" product what content she creates, how she thinks about onboarding, the systems she’s building, and how she’s learning to approach marketing with confidence and experimentation instead of overwhelm. Krista’s primary sales model...

info_outline
363 Find Your Farm’s Proof Sentence (That Helps Customers Say Yes Faster) show art 363 Find Your Farm’s Proof Sentence (That Helps Customers Say Yes Faster)

My Digital Farmer | Marketing Strategies for Farmers

What if one sentence could help your customers trust you faster? In this episode, I’m introducing a powerful marketing tool called a proof sentence — a simple line that helps your customer think, “Yeah… this is probably going to work for me, too.” A proof sentence doesn’t just describe your product. It shows what happens after someone buys it. We’ll talk about why promises are so powerful in marketing, how to identify the transformation your farm product creates, and how to build your own proof sentence using a simple formula. Because your customers aren’t just buying...

info_outline
362 How to Groom Your Farm Website During the Season show art 362 How to Groom Your Farm Website During the Season

My Digital Farmer | Marketing Strategies for Farmers

Is your farm website reflecting what’s happening on your farm RIGHT NOW… or is it stuck in last season? A few weeks ago, our farm was featured in the Toledo Blade newspaper during asparagus season, and suddenly we had a wave of new people discovering our business online. There was just one problem… Our website wasn’t ready for them. The homepage wasn’t talking about asparagus. There was no mention of the newspaper feature. And there wasn’t a clear next step for new visitors trying to figure out how to buy from us. That experience sparked a huge realization for me: Farm websites are...

info_outline
361 The Missing Piece in Your Farm Business: The Success Path show art 361 The Missing Piece in Your Farm Business: The Success Path

My Digital Farmer | Marketing Strategies for Farmers

May 13, 2026 There’s a missing piece in most farm marketing funnels, and it lives after the sale. If your customers feel overwhelmed, unsure what to do, or like they’re “failing” with your product… they don’t come back. In this episode, I’m breaking down the concept of a Success Path -- the intentional roadmap you build to guide your customer from confusion → confidence → transformation. When you build this well, you don’t just create repeat buyers… you create loyal fans who trust you, stick with you, and tell others. What You’ll Learn: What a Success Path actually...

info_outline
360 What to Do with Your Farm's Greatest Hits show art 360 What to Do with Your Farm's Greatest Hits

My Digital Farmer | Marketing Strategies for Farmers

I own every single album by the Indigo Girls. I’m a true fan. I know the deep cuts. The obscure songs. The ones most people have never heard of. But the album I reach for the most?...Their greatest hits. The one with all the favorites. The songs I already know I love. And it got me thinking… What if your farm had a “greatest hits album”? Most farmers are sitting on their most powerful sales tool… and not using it. Your best sellers—the products your customers already love—are doing more work than you think. But if you’re not intentionally leveraging them? You’re leaving...

info_outline
359 Are You Tracking This Number in Your Farm Business? show art 359 Are You Tracking This Number in Your Farm Business?

My Digital Farmer | Marketing Strategies for Farmers

What if the growth you’ve been chasing… isn’t actually about getting more customers? In this episode, I’m introducing a simple (but incredibly powerful) metric called Customer Value. And once you understand it, it will completely change how you think about your farm’s revenue, your marketing, and your growth strategy. Most farmers are focused on the wrong lever. They’re trying to bring in more people… when the real opportunity might already be sitting inside their current customer base. Inside this episode, I’m going to show you: What Customer Value actually is (and how to...

info_outline
358 Timing is Everything: The Best Time to Sell Your Farm Products show art 358 Timing is Everything: The Best Time to Sell Your Farm Products

My Digital Farmer | Marketing Strategies for Farmers

I walked into the grocery store this week… and it felt like Easter punched me in the face. Everywhere I turned, there were Easter baskets, chocolate bunnies, pastel packaging, even M&M’s rebranded as “eggs.” It wasn’t just a reminder that Easter was coming—it was a full-on invitation to buy like it was Easter. And here’s the weird part… I found myself wanting things I didn’t even plan to buy. If your farm products aren’t selling, it might not be your pricing… your offer… or even your marketing. It might be your timing. In this episode, I’m breaking down the 5...

info_outline
357 How I Built a Spring Plant Sale Launch That Sold Out in 48 Hours show art 357 How I Built a Spring Plant Sale Launch That Sold Out in 48 Hours

My Digital Farmer | Marketing Strategies for Farmers

We just sold out our entire Spring Plant Sale in 48 hours… and I had to shut the store down five days early. I don't think it was luck. This year, I approached the plant sale differently. I built it like a launch. And in the process, I uncovered a few new strategies (and a few surprising insights) that I haven’t shared before. If you’ve ever run a promotion and thought, “Why didn’t this sell as well as I hoped?”... this episode is your behind-the-scenes look at what actually moves the needle. I’m walking you through the anatomy of this year’s Spring Plant Sale launch -- what I...

info_outline
356 Inside a Farm Marketing School Coaching Call with MacKenzie Wright from Jones Brothers Farms show art 356 Inside a Farm Marketing School Coaching Call with MacKenzie Wright from Jones Brothers Farms

My Digital Farmer | Marketing Strategies for Farmers

What actually happens inside a Farm Marketing School coaching call? In this episode, you’re getting a rare, behind-the-scenes listen to a real 1:1 strategy session with MacKenzie Wright from , serving the Louisville and Northern Kentucky area with home-grown tomatoes, produce, and beef. In this conversation, we dig into social media strategy, what’s actually working, and how to think about content in a way that builds your email list—not just your follower count. We also explore what it looks like to step more fully into your role as the “face” of your brand… even when that feels a...

info_outline
355 The 3 Mindset Blocks Behind Selling Your Farm Products show art 355 The 3 Mindset Blocks Behind Selling Your Farm Products

My Digital Farmer | Marketing Strategies for Farmers

You don’t have a marketing problem. You have a hesitation problem. I see it all the time. Farmers build the offer. They may even grow the list. They do the marketing prep work. And when it’s time to promote?... They pull back. The question is why? This episode aims to uncover those beliefs quietly running your marketing. If you’ve ever thought: “I don’t want to be annoying.” “If they didn’t buy, maybe it’s me.” “Good products should just sell themselves.” You’re not alone. We dig into the three mindset blocks that keep farmers from selling confidently. We...

info_outline
 
More Episodes
Have you ever noticed how your mid-tier product seems to sell the best?
 
That’s not an accident.
 
This week I was researching pickleball memberships at Toledo Pickleball Club! And I noticed that I was drawn to a specific "tier" of membership from all the choices. And although it wasn't cheap, I still felt good about spending that much.
 
There’s a fascinating bit of sales psychology called the "compromise effect"—and today, we’re going to unpack what it is, why it works, and how you can use it to increase sales of specific items in your farm's product suite.
 
Your homework is to practice what you learn in today's episode and create 3 tiers of offers for this upcoming weekend. See if it doesn't double your sales!!

Podcast Sponsors:

Local Line:

Local Line is my preferred e-commerce platform for farmers. Are you looking for a new solution for your farm? I can't recommend it enough. Easy-to-use inventory management, great customer service, continuous improvement, and a culture dedicated to equipping farmers with marketing expertise. Local Line is offering a free premium feature for free for one year on top of your paid subscription. Claim your discount by signing up for a Local Line account today and using the coupon code: MDF2025. Head to my special affiliate link to get started: www.mydigitalfarmer.com/localline

Farm Marketing School:

Marketing doesn’t have to feel overwhelming! Farm Marketing School is my step-by-step system for building a profitable farm marketing plan. Inside, you'll get access to bite-sized marketing projects like:

  • 📆 Creating a promotion calendar that drives consistent sales
  • 🛠️ Setting up & optimizing your Google Business Profile
  • 📧 Writing high-converting emails (nurture, promotions, onboarding)
  • 🗣️ Collecting & using customer testimonials effectively
  • 🔍 Auditing & improving your sales funnel
  • 💬 Monthly live coaching calls for answers to your burning questions

Each project includes a workshop and step-by-step plan so you can take action and see results without the overwhelm. Join here:
👉 www.mydigitalfarmer.com/fms (Cancel anytime!)

Helpful Links Mentioned in This Episode

The NEW Social Media Planning Project launches live in Farm Marketing School, starting June 1st. Join us inside as we play in the social media sandbox, practice certain posts, and along the way, BUILD OUR 30 - Day Social System we can re-use every month!

What email provider do I use? I recommend Kit.com (formerly ConvertKit.com) -- it is easy to use, powerful, and getting better every year. It also integrates with most e-commerce providers and tools. Use my affiliate link!

Follow me on Instagram: @mydigitalfarmer

Episode 311 of the My Digital Farmer Podcast with Stacie Edwards was referenced in today's show. Stacie uses a LOT of store categories, and I read off ALL of them in this episode to give you inspiration for your own. I suggest you combine this tip with the idea of creating 3 tiers within your different categories, to point to the comromise offer.

Join My Email List: Get weekly farm marketing tips delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up at www.mydigitalfarmer.com/subscribe.

Want more farm marketing strategies? Visit my full resource library at www.mydigitalfarmer.com


💛 Support the Podcast:

Love the My Digital Farmer Podcast? You can help keep the show going!

  • Subscribe on your favorite podcast app so you never miss an episode.
  • ⭐️  Leave a Review on Apple Podcasts—it helps other farmers find the show.
  • Share this episode with a fellow farmer or small business owner.