Ep. 93 - The #1 Mistake Guys Make Buying Her a Ring (And How to Avoid It)
Release Date: 12/26/2025
Ep. 95 - Remembering Pat Finn
Buy Like a Guy
Pat Finn is a well-known actor, comedian, and writer with over 25 years of experience in the entertainment industry. He's appeared in numerous TV shows and movies, including The Middle, Seinfeld, “It’s Complicated,” and the “I Am Chris Farley” documentary. He has an almost endless list of professional accomplishments, and I wanted him on the show because he’s also a husband, father, and regular guy who really seems to “get” the whole jewelry thing. Here is Pat's IMDB link: We’re going to discuss his own experience of buying an engagement ring, how he was clueless...
info_outline
Ep. 94 - Get the Ring Right: Budget, Stones and Why Every Guy Needs a Good Jeweler
Buy Like a Guy
You survived the first round—now it’s time for the next level of buying her a ring. In Part II, Andy and Carter Eve dive into the stuff most guys never ask: setting a real budget (without three-months-salary BS), the truth about lab-grown vs. natural diamonds, and why having a trusted jeweler is your secret weapon. What You’ll Learn in This Episode: How to set a budget you won’t regret (and why it’s nobody’s business but yours) The pros and cons of lab-grown vs. natural diamonds—what actually matters, and what’s just hype How to redesign family rings without losing the...
info_outline
Ep. 93 - The #1 Mistake Guys Make Buying Her a Ring (And How to Avoid It)
Buy Like a Guy
Ever feel like buying an engagement ring is a minefield? You’re not alone. In this episode, Andy talks with Carter—a custom jeweler who’s helped hundreds of guys get it right—about the biggest mistakes men make, how to actually get her the ring she wants, and why the “surprise” isn’t what you think it is. What You’ll Learn in This Episode: The #1 mistake guys make when buying a ring—and how to avoid it Why just “surprising her” is mostly dead (and what actually works now) How to figure out her style (even if she sends you a million new ideas after you buy) The...
info_outline
Ep. 92 - Part II: The Truth About Natural Diamonds: Beauty, Character & Meaning
Buy Like a Guy
Ever wonder how a diamond actually gets from deep in the earth… to a jeweler’s case… to her hand? Part II of Andy’s conversation with Ari Jain from House of Diamonds uncovers the real, behind-the-scenes process of how natural diamonds are mined, cut, graded, and selected — long before a consumer ever sees them. If you’ve ever held a diamond and thought, “Why does this tiny thing cost so much?” This episode gives you an honest, insider explanation. Ari’s eight-generation lineage, starting in Jaipur’s royal courts, brings a rare perspective on craftsmanship,...
info_outline
Ep. 91 - Natural Diamonds: Nature's Greatest Masterpiece with Ari Jain
Buy Like a Guy
Thinking about buying an engagement ring — or trying to decide between a natural diamond and a lab-grown diamond? This episode cuts through all the noise, hype, and half-truths in the diamond world. Part I of Andy's conversation with Ari from House of Diamonds (an eight-generation diamond expert with roots in Jaipur's royal gemstone trade) dives into the emotional, spiritual, and practical realities of buying a natural diamond — from the meaning behind natural stones to why warmer colors are making a comeback. If you're a guy trying to buy the right stone for the woman you...
info_outline
Ep. 90 - How to Buy Your First Luxury Watch Without Getting Scammed
Buy Like a Guy
Thinking about buying your first real watch? Here's what the dealers won't tell you about ghost listings, fake prices, and why that "deal" you found online doesn't actually exist. Part II of Andy's conversation with Christian Bruhn from The Art of Time dives into the messy reality of buying luxury watches in 2025 — where online listings lie, auction prices mislead, and first-time buyers get burned by doing their own "research." What You'll Learn in This Episode: Ghost listings exposed: Why that Rolex Daytona you found online for $8K cheaper probably doesn't exist (and what luxury...
info_outline
Ep. 89 - The Art of Time: How to Buy a Real Watch with Christian Bruhn
Buy Like a Guy
When a guy decides he wants a real watch — something with meaning, quality, and story — he walks straight into a jungle of hype, counterfeits, and confusion. In this two-part conversation, Andy Koehn talks with Christian Bruhn, founder of The Art of Time and former member of the 75th Ranger Regiment, about the world of luxury watches, collecting with intention, and buying your first Rolex or high-end timepiece the right way. They cover everything from building trust in a world full of fakes to spotting real value, avoiding ghost listings, and understanding what makes a watch worth...
info_outline
Diamonds As Bad Investments
Buy Like a Guy
Episode Overview Andy takes on the YouTube critics and industry cynics head-on, delivering a family legacy perspective on why dismissing diamonds as "bad investments" completely misses the fucking point. From his grandfather's 1919 start in the business to today's lab-grown revolution, this episode cuts through the financial advisor bullshit to reveal what diamonds are really worth. Key Takeaways The Investment Reality Check: Not once has Andy heard someone say "I'd like your finest appreciating asset, please" Diamonds end up on fingers of teachers, truck drivers, accountants - people marking...
info_outline
The Four C's (Part 2)-Clarity and Carat Weight
Buy Like a Guy
Chapter 2: The Four C's (Part 2) Episode Overview Andy finishes the Four C's conversation with Clarity and Carat Weight, delivers his legendary Diamond-to-Steak conversion chart, and cuts through the industry's microscopic bullshit to give you what actually matters when you're standing in that jewelry store. Key Takeaways The Clarity Reality Check: She doesn't need a flawless diamond unless she specifically asked for one - she just wants it to look that way Clarity grades are determined by gemologists with microscopes, not naked eyes in natural lighting The difference between...
info_outline
The Four C's (Part 1)
Buy Like a Guy
Episode Overview Andy breaks down the diamond industry's "sacred scripture" - the Four C's - but cuts through the BS to give you what you actually need to know. This is part one of a two-part deep dive into diamond grading, focusing on Cut and Color. Key Takeaways The Bottom Line on Diamond Education: You'll spend roughly 2 hours of your entire life discussing the Four C's Don't overthink it - learn enough to have an intelligent conversation with a pro Find someone you trust to guide you through the rest Why the Four C's Exist: Created by GIA in the 1940s to standardize diamond grading...
info_outlineEver feel like buying an engagement ring is a minefield? You’re not alone. In this episode, Andy talks with Carter—a custom jeweler who’s helped hundreds of guys get it right—about the biggest mistakes men make, how to actually get her the ring she wants, and why the “surprise” isn’t what you think it is.
What You’ll Learn in This Episode:
- The #1 mistake guys make when buying a ring—and how to avoid it
- Why just “surprising her” is mostly dead (and what actually works now)
- How to figure out her style (even if she sends you a million new ideas after you buy)
- The right way to use family stones and heirlooms without losing meaning
- How to handle the money talk (and why the price is nobody’s business but yours)
- Real-world advice for guys who feel lost or overwhelmed by the process
- Why finding “your jeweler” matters more than any brand or store
Key Quotes from Carter:
“The most common mistake guys make is thinking they know what she wants, instead of actually checking with her—or her mom, sister, or best friend.”
“Jewelry is personal. If it’s not her style, she won’t wear it, even if you love it.”
“Don’t let anyone pressure you. Take your time, ask questions, and get educated.”
Why This Episode Matters for Guys Buying Rings:
If you’re worried about blowing it, or just want to get it right the first time, this episode gives you the real-world playbook:
- How to get her style right (even if she “changes her mind” halfway through)
- What to do with family rings and old gold
- How to set a budget you’re actually comfortable with—no three-months-salary BS
- Why collaborating with a jeweler you trust makes the whole process easier (and way less stressful)
Carter’s Top Advice:
- Don’t guess. Ask her, or ask her inner circle.
- If she says “surprise me,” a classic round solitaire is your safest bet.
- Check her Pinterest or Instagram—the answer is probably there.
- Set your own budget—never go into debt for a ring.
- Find a jeweler who feels like “your guy”—someone you can text, call, and trust.
Who Is Carter?
Carter Eve is a custom jeweler, trained goldsmith, and owner of Carter Eve Jewelry, known for heirloom redesigns, value-driven sourcing, and an authentic approach to jewelry design. She helps guys get the ring right—without the hype or pressure, which makes her a perfect guest for the show.
Resources Mentioned:
- Carter Eve Jewelry: https://
carterevejewelry.com/ - Andy’s book: The Inappropriate Guide to Buying an Engagement Ring available on Amazon.
Connect with Buy Like A Guy:
Email Andy at andy@buylikeaguy.com
Music credits: Preacher Man by Miles Neilson and The Rusted Hearts, used with permission. A killer band with original songs that get stuck in your head. They're awesome.
Listen To Preacher Man on Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/track/7ImcaJKIk0ZVtPzuUVV4vc?si=80581c74a9be4987