loader from loading.io

E64: Why Estimation In Game Dev Is So Hard

Building Better Games

Release Date: 06/04/2024

E87: Toxic Culture in Game Development: The Real Metrics That Matter with Charlie Sull show art E87: Toxic Culture in Game Development: The Real Metrics That Matter with Charlie Sull

Building Better Games

How would you know if your studio’s culture is toxic—before it’s too late? In this exclusive conversation, we talk with Charlie Sull, co-founder of CultureX and researcher with MIT, about how to spot, measure, and fix toxic workplace culture—especially in the high-stakes world of game development. Forget ping pong tables and free snacks. Culture is your operating system, and if leaders don’t prioritize it, dysfunction spreads fast. We break down: What creates a toxic culture The Toxic Five behaviors that damage morale and hurt retention Why standard employee surveys fail—and what...

info_outline
E86: Why User Acquisition Isn't Just For Mobile Anymore with Matej Lančarič show art E86: Why User Acquisition Isn't Just For Mobile Anymore with Matej Lančarič

Building Better Games

Building a great game is hard—but getting players to actually discover and play it? That’s often harder. In this episode of Building Better Games, Ben sits down with user acquisition expert Matej Lančarič, whose decade of experience spans mobile, PC, Steam, and cross-platform launches. Together, they dive deep into the realities of user acquisition (UA), creative strategy, and why great games still fail without a clear plan to get players in the door. We break down: What “user acquisition” really means in 2024 Why CPI, LTV, ROAS, and retention all matter—but don’t tell the whole...

info_outline
E85: Why Your Game Vision Sucks (And Why You're Not Alone!) with Graham McAllister show art E85: Why Your Game Vision Sucks (And Why You're Not Alone!) with Graham McAllister

Building Better Games

In this episode, we welcome back organizational psychologist Graham McAllister for part 3 of our deep dive into one of the most critical challenges in game development—game vision. If you're a game developer, leader, or aspiring leader, this is an essential conversation that exposes why studios struggle to align on vision and how that misalignment contributes to failed games, frustrated teams, and organizational friction. Graham shares exclusive insights from his groundbreaking research, revealing why even seasoned studios misfire on creating shared mental models and what happens when...

info_outline
E84: The Real Cost Of Founding A Game Startup with Joseph Kim show art E84: The Real Cost Of Founding A Game Startup with Joseph Kim

Building Better Games

The gaming industry is changing rapidly, and the global landscape is shifting in ways many studios aren’t prepared for. Are Western game studios becoming too complacent? What role will international development play in the future of game creation? In this episode, Joseph Kim, CEO of Lila Games, shares hard-earned lessons about building a game studio in India, the challenges of hiring and leading globally, and the realities of making tough business decisions in game development. Key Takeaways: The Complacency Problem – Many Western studios lack the urgency and work ethic to stay...

info_outline
E83: 3 Steps To Leading Well In Game Development show art E83: 3 Steps To Leading Well In Game Development

Building Better Games

What does it take to lead effectively in the gaming industry? Many leaders in game development step into their roles without formal training—learning through trial and error. In this episode, we break down what real leadership looks like, how to avoid common pitfalls, and how to drive meaningful change without falling into the trap of just "managing" processes.   Key Takeaways: The difference between management vs. leadership in game dev How to set and maintain the right goals for your team Avoiding false urgency and overconfidence in decision-making Why building trust and influence is...

info_outline
E82: The Art & Science of Game Prototyping with Leif Johansen show art E82: The Art & Science of Game Prototyping with Leif Johansen

Building Better Games

What if everything you thought about prototyping was wrong? Many teams rush to validate an idea too soon, but what if the real secret to success is building a studio that learns better? In this episode, Leif Johansen breaks down the myths of prototyping and how studios can create a structured approach to experimenting with game ideas.   Key Takeaways: - Stop Searching for the “Perfect Prototype” – The best teams prioritize many small, fast failures over one high-stakes prototype. - Prototyping Is a Science and an Art – The most successful studios create intentional experiments...

info_outline
E81: Why You Aren’t Ready for Where Game Dev Is Going with Leif Johansen show art E81: Why You Aren’t Ready for Where Game Dev Is Going with Leif Johansen

Building Better Games

Is the games industry maturing or collapsing? How have our old models and comparisons hurt how we develop? In this episode, Leif walks us through how game dev has shifted, and how you need to think differently to stay relevant. Enjoy!   Key Takeaways: Playtesting and Leadership: How leaders set the tone for playtesting with their behavior, not their words. The Slow Rise of “Forever” Games: How players spending more time in older games is reshaping play patterns. Drinking Our Own Kool-aid: Too many games have an expectation that they’ll wildly succeed and make decisions that cause...

info_outline
E80: How UGC Is Transforming The Games Industry with Bungie and Look North World Founder Alex Seropian show art E80: How UGC Is Transforming The Games Industry with Bungie and Look North World Founder Alex Seropian

Building Better Games

Why did Bungie's founder leave the AAA world to start building games in UEFN? What are the advantages and challenges of UGC platforms? Today, we talk with Alex Seropian, veteran game designer and founder of Bungie and Look North World, about the future of our industry. Enjoy!   Key Takeaways: UGC Platforms Provide Some Serious Advantages: Tools like Fortnite Creative and Roblox empower creators, enabling rapid prototyping and innovation. Game Dev is Evolving: The shift from small teams to massive AAA productions introduces challenges beyond what we expected and that remain unsolved....

info_outline
E79: Why AAA is Failing and How to Recover and Other Questions - Our First Q&A Episode! show art E79: Why AAA is Failing and How to Recover and Other Questions - Our First Q&A Episode!

Building Better Games

No guests today! Instead, I'll be taking questions from the Building Better Games discord and answering them. I cover10 questions including the challenges with AAA dev, the rise of co-dev, and what production careers look like. Enjoy! Question #1 : How do you ensure that you (the royal you) are making a game that will be fun for players, not just fun for its designers to make? (Or maybe in this context - what are the ways in which production can support product management and ensure the sprint-to-sprint goals align with what internal player advocates are asking for?) Question #2...

info_outline
E78: How to Lead Game Dev in Uncertain Times, with Omar Kendall show art E78: How to Lead Game Dev in Uncertain Times, with Omar Kendall

Building Better Games

There’s a ton of knowledge about how we sustain games, but the art of creating something new remains mysterious, even to veteran developers. In this episode, Omar Kendall returns to talk about unknowns, product vs design, and how our industry is relating to risk. Enjoy!   Key Takeaways: Embrace Uncertainty: Build teams ready to solve the riskiest problems first. Early Feedback Wins: Engaging players early reduces risks and validates ideas. Product vs. Design: Learn the difference between identifying opportunities and crafting solutions. Innovation Thrives in Small Teams: Smaller, lean...

info_outline
 
More Episodes

In this episode of "Building Better Games," hosts Benjamin Carcich and Aaron Smith dive into the complex and often frustrating topic of estimation and planning in game development. They address the challenges, misconceptions, and emotional reactions surrounding estimation, drawing on their extensive experience in the industry. The episode also covers current trends in game development, including the ongoing issue of layoffs and economic pressures affecting studios.

 

Key Points:

  1. Challenges of Estimation:

    • Estimation is a universal pain point in game development, often leading to frustration and cynicism.
    • The misconception that precise estimates can accurately predict future outcomes is widespread and problematic.
  2. The Importance of Flexibility:

    • Effective estimation requires flexibility in scope, time, resources, and priorities.
    • Establishing clear levers that can be pulled to adjust plans as needed is crucial for successful project management.
  3. Relative Estimation and Calibration:

    • Estimations should focus on accuracy rather than precision, using confidence intervals to provide a more realistic view of project timelines.
    • Techniques like throughput and relative estimation help teams make faster and more reliable predictions.
  4. Prioritization and Learning:

    • Estimations are valuable for prioritizing tasks and understanding the relative importance of different features.
    • Tracking past performance and learning from previous estimates can improve future predictions and planning.
  5. Balancing Creativity and Control:

    • Overly rigid plans can stifle creativity and lead to subpar games.
    • Creating systems that allow developers to exercise their judgment and creativity is essential for producing high-quality games.
  6. Trust and Communication:

    • Building trust between managers and teams is vital for effective estimation and planning.
    • Clear communication about the realities of project timelines and the inherent uncertainties in game development is necessary.
  7. Tools and Techniques:

    • Various estimation techniques, including ideal days, story points, and throughput, offer different benefits and can be tailored to specific project needs.
    • The hosts emphasize the importance of choosing the right method for the context and being willing to adapt as new information emerges.

By addressing these points, Ben and Aaron provide valuable insights into how to navigate the complexities of estimation and planning in game development, ultimately helping studios ship better games with less stress and frustration.

 

Our discord community is live! Join here to engage with leaders and producers in game dev looking to make our industry a better place that makes better games: https://discord.gg/ySCPS5aMcQ

 

And if you're interested in more of our content, links below.

"Succeeding in Game Production: What You Aren't Taught" online course for game producers: https://www.buildingbettergames.gg/succeeding-in-game-production 

Newsletter: https://www.buildingbettergames.gg/newsletter 

Ben's LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/benjamin-carcich/

Aaron's LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/doublearon00/

YouTube Channel: https://www.youtube.com/@buildingbettergames